PLACEBO-EFFECT OF NITRATE MONOTHERAPY FOR MYOCARDIAL-ISCHEMIA

Nitrate monotherapy was assessed by treadmill exercise stress testing in 18 patients with significant but relatively asymptomatic myocardial ischemia who were receiving no other antianginal therapy. In addition, prolonged ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring was performed in 7 patients with demonstrable ischemia during baseline monitoring. After baseline assessment, 5 treatment periods were used in a random order (each of 1 week duration), incorporating 2 dose levels of transdermal nitrate (10 and 20 mg/24 hours) and isosorbide dinitrate (ISDN) (30 and 60 mg/day in divided doses) with a 10-hour nitrate-free interval every 24 hours, as well as a placebo period using a double-blind technique. All treatment periods (including placebo) showed a significant (p <0.01) 45 to 69% prolongation in the time to 1 mm ST depression during exercise. Paired baseline times of 231 +/- 28 and 233 +/- 30 seconds increased to 367 +/- 37 seconds with 30 mg/day of ISDN, 393 +/- 37 seconds with 60 mg/day of ISDN, 381 +/- 31 seconds with 10 mg/day of transdermal nitrate, and 372 +/- 33 seconds with 20 mg/day of transdermal nitrate. The value for placebo was 342 +/- 29 seconds, which was not significantly different from active treatment (p >0.1). Some patients appeared to individually respond to greater-than-or-equal-to 1 nitrate preparation significantly more than to placebo, but this appeared to be unpredictable and largely independent of dosage level and route of administration. There was a qualitatively similar but statistically insignificant reduction in total ischemic time during ambulatory monitoring. No significant effects on total exercise duration or heart rate/systolic pressure product at 1 mm ST depression or end exercise were observed. It is concluded that nitrate monotherapy produces a clinically important effect in delaying the onset of myocardial ischemia during exercise, but there was also a large placebo response in this particular patient group, and thus, no drug-specific effects of nitrate monotherapy on myocardial ischemia could be reliably demonstrated.