ECHOGRAPHIC MONITORING OF RESPONSE OF EXTRAOCULAR-MUSCLES TO IRRADIATION IN GRAVES OPHTHALMOPATHY

Purpose: Confirmation of the efficacy of orbital irradiation in Graves' ophthalmopathy is needed due to the unpredictable natural history of the disease, the variation in individual clinical presentations, the contribution of other simultaneous treatments, and the lack of controlled studies using objective criteria to classify and assess response over time. Orbital echography before and at select intervals following orbital irradiation is proposed as an objective parameter of tissue response to orbital irradiation over time. Methods and Materials: From January, 1983 to September, 1993, 55 patients with progressive Graves' ophthalmopathy underwent 20 Gy retrobulbar irradiation. On retrospective review, standardized orbital echography was performed randomly prior to irradiation in 37 of the 55 patients to assess the acoustic characteristics of the extraocular muscles and to quantitate their individual and summed diameters. Twenty-one patients had at least one follow-up echographic evaluation at random intervals of 0 to 27.5 months following completion of irradiation, Twelve patients received steroids before or during irradiation, which were tapered in proximity to completion of radiation. Follow-up ranged from 2 to 65 months with the majority followed at least 6 months (18 patients). Results: Of the 21 patients with serial studies, 18 showed an interval decrease in individual and summed muscle size over time and return of symmetry, Interval improvement was documented as early as the 1 month follow-up study, with continued improvement seen during the 3-9-month studies, with stability typically achieved within 12 months. One patient had further changes between the 21 and 27.5 month follow-up studies. Exacerbation of disease was, however, echographically demonstrated in three patients at 6.5, 8.5, and 13 months, Follow-up studies in two of these patients again revealed improvement, one following tapered steroids, The third patient required orbital decompression. Conclusion: Objective parameters of response are needed to document both the immediate and long-term outcome of orbital irradiation on the course of Graves' ophthalmopathy and confirm its efficacy. Serial echography is proposed as a new technique for providing parameters to judge response.