RADIOIODINE ABLATION OF RESIDUAL TISSUE IN THYROID-CANCER - RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ADMINISTERED ACTIVITY, NECK UPTAKE AND OUTCOME

A retrospective review was performed to evaluate the effectiveness of radioiodine in the ablation of residual thyroid tissue after surgery for differentiated thyroid cancer. 121 patients were treated at the Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, Canada between 1977 and 1989, with the activity of radioiodine determined empirically. Ablation of residual thyroid was determined by I-131 nuclear scans, using absent visible uptake (compared with background) as the criterion for successful ablation. 97 patients (80%) had successful ablation of residual thyroid tissue after the first administration of radioiodine. Patients with higher iodine uptake in the neck had a tendency to receive higher activities of I-131. There were no statistically significant differences in age, sex, type of surgery, initial iodine uptake in the neck and administered radioiodine activity between those successfully ablated and those that were not. Patients receiving less than 3.7 GBq (100 mCi) tended to have lower iodine uptake (<5% at 24 or 48 h), but their rate of thyroid ablation was just as high as those given 3.7 GBq or more. In order to take advantage of this, we have formalized our approach by deriving guidelines to the empiric determination of radioiodine activity based on the iodine uptake in the neck. Among the 11 patients treated with lobectomy only, the ablation rate was 64%. Although this was not significantly lower than for other forms of surgery, we continue to recommend completion thyroidectomy for this group of patients, if the goal of treatment is to ablate all thyroid tissue.