THE ROLE OF CHEMOTHERAPY IN THE TREATMENT OF CHILDREN WITH NEUROBLASTOMA STAGE-IV - THE GPO (GERMAN-PEDIATRIC-ONCOLOGY-SOCIETY) EXPERIENCE

被引:59
作者
BERTHOLD, F
BURDACH, S
KREMENS, B
LAMPERT, F
NIETHAMMER, D
RIEHM, H
RITTER, J
TREUNER, J
UTSCH, S
ZIESCHANG, J
机构
[1] UNIV DUSSELDORF,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-4000 DUSSELDORF 1,GERMANY
[2] UNIV ESSEN GESAMTHSCH,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-4300 ESSEN 1,GERMANY
[3] UNIV GIESSEN,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-6300 GIESSEN,GERMANY
[4] UNIV TUBINGEN,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-7400 TUBINGEN 1,GERMANY
[5] UNIV HANOVER,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-3000 HANOVER,GERMANY
[6] UNIV MUNSTER,KINDERKLINIKEN,W-4400 MUNSTER,GERMANY
来源
KLINISCHE PADIATRIE | 1990年 / 202卷 / 04期
关键词
D O I
10.1055/s-2007-1025531
中图分类号
R72 [儿科学];
学科分类号
100202 ;
摘要
340 consecutive patients with neuroblastoma stage IV were analyzed for the possible impact of chemotherapy on general condition, remission status, event free survival and survival. The children entered the trials NB 79, NB 82 and NB 85 of the German Pediatric Oncology Society (GPO). The patients did benefit from chemotherapy by considerable improvement of the general condition, by achievement of 30-40% complete and 60-70% partial remissions. The event free survival (EFS) rate 5-8 years after diagnosis was 13% for all 299 protocol patients, the survival (S) rate 10%. The median/mean EFS time were 11.6/23.8 months, the median/mean S time 17.0/29.4 months. The use of response rates as early predictors for long term survival is challenged. Addition of PCVm (cisplatinum, cyclophosphamide, Vm 26) to ACVD (adriamycine, cyclophosphamide, vincristine, dacarbazine) in trial NB 82 resulted in an improvement of the long term EFS rate from 5% to 18% (S rates 7 → 21%). The introduction of IVp (ifosfamide, VP16) and increase of doses (cisplatinum, Vm 26) did not further improve the results. Maintenance therapy (NB 82) revealed a positive influence on the outcome. Shorter intervals for realization of chemotherapy were associated with a trend for better EFS (NB 85). Although the group of children with bone marrow transplantation showed better EFS and S data compared to the unselected chemotherapy group, the advantage was less clear if matched pairs (remission status at the time of BMT) were compared. We conclude from our series that data for further increasing the chemotherapeutic aggressiveness in the treatment of children with stage IV neuroblastoma currently do not exist, but prolongation of the chemotherapy phase might be a worthwhile consideration for future trials.
引用
收藏
页码:262 / 269
页数:8
相关论文
共 15 条
  • [1] SEQUENTIAL CISPLATIN-VM-26 AND VINCRISTINE CYCLOPHOSPHAMIDE DOXORUBICIN IN METASTATIC NEUROBLASTOMA - AN EFFECTIVE ALTERNATING NON-CROSS-RESISTANT REGIMEN
    BERNARD, JL
    PHILIP, T
    ZUCKER, JM
    FRAPPAZ, D
    ROBERT, A
    MARGUERITTE, G
    BOILLETOT, A
    PHILIPPE, N
    LUTZ, P
    ROCHE, H
    PINKERTON, R
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 1987, 5 (12) : 1952 - 1959
  • [2] BERTHOLD F, 1990, IN PRESS AM J PEDIAT
  • [3] BERTHOLD F, 1986, MONOGR PAEDIATR, V18, P206
  • [4] BERTHOLD F, 1990, IN PRESS MONOGR PAED
  • [5] INTERNATIONAL CRITERIA FOR DIAGNOSIS, STAGING, AND RESPONSE TO TREATMENT IN PATIENTS WITH NEURO-BLASTOMA
    BRODEUR, GM
    SEEGER, RC
    BARRETT, A
    BERTHOLD, F
    CASTLEBERRY, RP
    DANGIO, G
    DEBERNARDI, B
    EVANS, AE
    FAVROT, M
    FREEMAN, AI
    HAASE, G
    HARTMANN, O
    HAYES, FA
    HELSON, L
    KEMSHEAD, J
    LAMPERT, F
    NINANE, J
    OHKAWA, H
    PHILIP, T
    PINKERTON, CR
    PRITCHARD, J
    SAWADA, T
    SIEGEL, S
    SMITH, EI
    TSUCHIDA, Y
    VOUTE, PA
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 1988, 6 (12) : 1874 - 1881
  • [6] CARLSEN NLT, 1989, ANTICANCER RES, V9, P837
  • [7] RESISTANT AND RELAPSING NEUROBLASTOMA - IMPROVED RESPONSE RATE WITH A NEW MULTIAGENT REGIMEN (OC-HDP) INCLUDING HIGH-DOSE CISPLATINUM
    DINI, G
    LANINO, E
    ROGERS, D
    GARAVENTA, A
    PERIN, G
    STURA, M
    DALLORSO, S
    CORNAGLIAFERRARIS, P
    DEBERNARDI, B
    [J]. MEDICAL AND PEDIATRIC ONCOLOGY, 1987, 15 (01): : 18 - 23
  • [8] EVANS AE, 1971, CANCER, V27, P374, DOI 10.1002/1097-0142(197102)27:2<374::AID-CNCR2820270221>3.0.CO
  • [9] 2-G
  • [10] MULTIAGENT CHEMOTHERAPY FOR CHILDREN WITH METASTATIC NEURO-BLASTOMA - REPORT FROM CHILDRENS CANCER STUDY-GROUP
    FINKLESTEIN, JZ
    KLEMPERER, MR
    EVANS, A
    BERNSTEIN, I
    LEIKIN, S
    MCCREADIE, S
    GROSFELD, J
    HITTLE, R
    WEINER, J
    SATHER, H
    HAMMOND, D
    [J]. MEDICAL AND PEDIATRIC ONCOLOGY, 1979, 6 (02): : 179 - 188