EFFECT OF HOMEOPATHY ON PAIN AND OTHER EVENTS AFTER ACUTE TRAUMA - PLACEBO-CONTROLLED TRIAL WITH BILATERAL ORAL-SURGERY

被引:40
作者
LOKKEN, P
STRAUMSHEIM, PA
TVEITEN, D
SKJELBRED, P
BORCHGREVINK, CF
机构
[1] UNIV OSLO,DENT PHARMACOL & PHARMACOTHERAPEUT SECT,N-0316 OSLO,NORWAY
[2] ST HANSHAUGEN MED CTR,N-0168 OSLO,NORWAY
[3] NORWEGIAN INST NAT MED,N-1340 BEKKESTUA,NORWAY
[4] OSLO CITY HOSP,MAXILLOFACIAL SURG SECT,N-0407 OSLO,NORWAY
[5] UNIV OSLO,DEPT GEN PRACTICE,N-0264 OSLO,NORWAY
关键词
D O I
10.1136/bmj.310.6992.1439
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective-To examine whether homoeopathy has any effect on pain and other inflammatory events after surgery. Design-Randomised double blind, placebo controlled crossover trial with ''identical'' oral surgical procedures performed on two separate occasions in 24 patients. Interventions-Treatment started 3 hours after surgery with either homoeopathy or placebo. Main outcome measures-Postoperative pain and preference for postoperative course assessed by patients on visual analogue scales. Measurements of postoperative swelling and reduction in ability to open mouth. Assessment of bleeding after surgery. Results-Pain after surgery was essentially the same whether treated with homoeopathy or placebo. Postoperative swelling was not significantly affected by homoeopathy, but treatment tended to give less reduction in ability to open mouth. No noticeable difference was seen in postoperative bleeding, side effects, or complaints. Thirteen of the 24 patients preferred the postoperative course with placebo. Conclusions-No positive evidence was found for efficacy of homoeopathic treatment on pain and other inflammatory events after an acute soft tissue and bone injury inflicted by a surgical intervention. Differences in the order of 30% to 40% would have been needed to show significant effects.
引用
收藏
页码:1439 / 1442
页数:4
相关论文
共 23 条
[1]  
Albertini H, 1985, J AM I HOMEOPATH, V3, P126
[2]   BILATERAL SURGICAL REMOVAL OF IMPACTED MANDIBULAR 3RD MOLAR TEETH AS A MODEL FOR DRUG EVALUATION - TEST WITH OXYPHENBUTAZONE (TANDERIL) [J].
ALBUM, B ;
OLSEN, I ;
LOKKEN, P .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ORAL SURGERY, 1977, 6 (03) :177-189
[3]   WHAT DOES HOMEOPATHT DO AND HOW [J].
BUCKMAN, R ;
LEWITH, G .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 309 (6947) :103-106
[4]  
Campbell A., 1976, BR HOMOEOPATH J, V65, P154
[5]   REPEATED MEASURES IN CLINICAL-TRIALS - ANALYSIS USING MEAN SUMMARY STATISTICS AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR DESIGN [J].
FRISON, L ;
POCOCK, SJ .
STATISTICS IN MEDICINE, 1992, 11 (13) :1685-1704
[6]  
GIBSON DM, 1972, BRIT HOMOEOPATHY J, V61, P167
[7]  
IVES G, 1984, COMMUNICATIONS MIDLA, V11, P71
[8]  
Jones B., 1989, DESIGN ANAL CROSS OV
[9]  
KAZIRO GSN, 1984, BRIT J ORAL MAX SURG, V22, P42, DOI 10.1016/0266-4356(84)90007-X
[10]   CLINICAL-TRIALS OF HOMEOPATHY [J].
KLEIJNEN, J ;
KNIPSCHILD, P ;
TERRIET, G .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1991, 302 (6772) :316-323