RECALL AND LANGUAGE USAGE IN RETELLINGS OF TELEVISED AND PRINTED STORIES

被引:12
作者
BEENTJES, JWJ
VANDERVOORT, THA
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1016/0304-422X(91)90035-N
中图分类号
I [文学];
学科分类号
05 ;
摘要
Directly after story presentation and two to three weeks later, children from grades 4 (N=44) and 6(N=44) retold two stories that were either read by children or presented to them as a television film. Retelling were analyzed for correctness and completeness of story recall, and specify of language usage. As predicted, recall of the film and the printed story varied with children's age and complete than their recall of the printed story, whereas sixth-graders' recall was almost independent of the medium used. After two to three weeks, recall of the printed stories had deteriorated considerably more than recall of televised stories. Reading a story resulted in more additional descriptions of story elements than watching a TV film, although after two to three weeks this effect had disappeared. Children who watched a film referred more specifically to story characters than those who read a print version of the story, a finding that is probably attributable to the nature of the print version used. © 1991.
引用
收藏
页码:91 / 104
页数:14
相关论文
共 14 条
[1]   STRUCTURALLY EQUIVALENT STORIES IN MOVIE AND TEXT AND THE EFFECT OF THE MEDIUM ON RECALL [J].
BAGGETT, P .
JOURNAL OF VERBAL LEARNING AND VERBAL BEHAVIOR, 1979, 18 (03) :333-356
[2]  
BAGGETT P, 1983, ECTJ-EDUC COMMUN TEC, V31, P23
[3]   SPECIFIC IMPACT OF RADIO AND TELEVISION ON CHILDRENS STORY COMPREHENSION [J].
BEAGLESROOS, J ;
GAT, I .
JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1983, 75 (01) :128-137
[4]  
BEENTJES JWJ, 1989, PEDAGOG STUD, V66, P147
[5]  
FRY E, 1977, J READING, V21, P242
[6]   YOUNG CHILDRENS RECALL AND RECONSTRUCTION OF AUDIO AND AUDIOVISUAL NARRATIVES [J].
GIBBONS, J ;
ANDERSON, DR ;
SMITH, R ;
FIELD, DE ;
FISCHER, C .
CHILD DEVELOPMENT, 1986, 57 (04) :1014-1023
[7]   RADIO VS TELEVISION - THEIR COGNITIVE IMPACT ON CHILDREN OF DIFFERENT SOCIOECONOMIC AND ETHNIC-GROUPS [J].
GREENFIELD, P ;
BEAGLESROOS, J .
JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATION, 1988, 38 (02) :71-92
[8]  
Greenfield Patricia M., 1984, MIND MEDIA EFFECTS T
[9]  
HAYES DS, 1985, MERRILL PALMER QUART, V31, P345
[10]  
HAYES DS, 1986, J EDUC PSYCHOL, V78, P341, DOI DOI 10.1037/0022-0663.78.5.341