A WARD COMPARISON BETWEEN THE ONE TOUCH-II AND GLUCOMETER-II BLOOD-GLUCOSE METERS

被引：11

作者：

KILPATRICK, ES

MCLEOD, MJ

RUMLEY, AG

SMALL, M

机构：

[1] Department of Pathological Biochemistry, Western Infirmary, Glasgow

[2] Diabetic Unit, Gartnavel General Hospital, Glasgow

来源：

DIABETIC MEDICINE | 1994年 / 11卷 / 02期

关键词：

GLUCOSE TEST STRIPS; METERS; BLOOD GLUCOSE MONITORING;

D O I：

10.1111/j.1464-5491.1994.tb02023.x

中图分类号：

R5 [内科学];

学科分类号：

1002 ; 100201 ;

摘要：

A 6-week clinical evaluation of the One Touch 11 blood glucose meter was performed in a medical ward specializing in diabetic patients and compared to the existing Glucometer II system. Nursing staff trained in both methods performed 267 capillary blood glucose measurements using the two meters.A reference capillary blood glucose was performed simultaneously on 129 of these occasions using a Yellow Springs Instrument analyser. The One Touch II correlated better with the reference (r = 0.97) than the Glucometer II (r = 0.86) and was equally close or closer to the Yellow Springs Instrument on 82 % of occasions. A greater proportion of samples measured by the One Touch II were within 15% of the reference value (83 % vs 66 %). There were also 17 cases where the One Touch II was able to give a measurement which was outwith the analytical range of the Glucometer II. A questionnaire revealed the nursing staff unanimously preferred using the One Touch II to their present meter. It is concluded that in a ward setting the One Touch II meter showed improved accuracy, usefulness in its wider analytical range, and a greater user preference in comparison to the Glucometer II.

引用

页码：214 / 217

页数：4

共 10 条

[1]

Brooks KE, Rawal N, Henderson AR, Laboratory assessment of three new monitors of blood glucose, AccuChek II, Glucometer II and Glucosan 2000, Clin Chem, 32, pp. 2195-2200, (1986)

[2]

Begley JP, Forrest ARW, Laboratory assessment of three reflectance meters designed for self monitoring of blood glucose concentrations, J Clin Path, 41, pp. 397-402, (1988)

[3]

Wysocki T, Impact of blood glucose monitoring on diabetic control: Obstacles and interventions, J Behav Med, 12, pp. 183-205, (1989)

[4]

Burrin JM, Newton-Adair I, Fyffe JA, Performance of the Reflocheck system used outside the laboratory by trained non‐laboratory personnel, Practical Diabetes, 4, pp. 167-172, (1987)

[5]

Rayman G, Hospital in‐patient monitoring of diabetes, Practical Diabetes, 2, pp. 62-64, (1989)

[6]

Self‐monitoring of blood glucose, Diabetes Care, 15, pp. 56-61, (1992)

[7]

Kilpatrick ES, Rumley AG, Small M, Evaluation of the One Touch II Blood Glucose Meter, Proceedings of the Association of Clinical Biochemists National Meeting, (1993)

[8]

Bland JM, Altman DG, Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement, Lancet, 1, pp. 307-310, (1986)

[9]

Bedside Blood Glucose Monitoring in Hospitals, Diabetes Care, 15, (1992)

[10]

Kilpatrick ES, Rumley AG, Dominiczak MH, Small M, The effect of variations in haematocrit, mean cell volume and red blood cell count on reagent strip tests for glucose, Ann Clin Biochem, (1993)

← 1 →