IMPROVING RATING-SCALE MEASURES BY DETECTING AND CORRECTING BIAS COMPONENTS IN SOME RESPONSE STYLES

被引:162
作者
GREENLEAF, EA
机构
关键词
D O I
10.2307/3172568
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
The author examines whether the response styles of yeasaying and standard deviation in rating scale responses convey information on respondents' attitudes or create bias that distorts attitude information and marketing research. A method is proposed to identify attitude information components and bias components in response styles, using prediction errors in attitude-behavior models. Analysis of data from a large-scale consumer survey supports the presence of both attitude information and bias components in standard deviation, and an attitude information but not a bias component in yeasaying. This finding suggests that correcting rating scale data by removing the bias but not the attitude information in standard deviation can increase the accuracy of survey research. Examples are given of how bias in standard deviation, and the scoring correction, affect segmentation research.
引用
收藏
页码:176 / 188
页数:13
相关论文
共 30 条
[11]   CRITERIAL RANGE AS A FRAME OF REFERENCE FOR STIMULUS JUDGMENT [J].
GRAVETTER, F ;
LOCKHEAD, GR .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REVIEW, 1973, 80 (03) :203-216
[12]  
GREENLEAF EA, IN PRESS PUBLIC OPIN
[13]  
Gruber RE, 1983, RES METHODS CAUSAL M, P131
[14]   PERSONALITY ATTRIBUTES ASSOCIATED WITH EXTREME RESPONSE STYLE [J].
HAMILTON, DL .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1968, 69 (03) :192-&
[15]   THE INSTABILITY OF RESPONSE SETS [J].
HUI, CH ;
TRIANDIS, HC .
PUBLIC OPINION QUARTERLY, 1985, 49 (02) :253-260
[16]   PERSONALITY DIMENSIONS AND EXTREME RESPONSE TENDENCY [J].
IWAWAKI, S ;
ZAX, M .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORTS, 1969, 25 (01) :31-&
[17]   CONTENT AND STYLE IN PERSONALITY-ASSESSMENT [J].
JACKSON, DN ;
MESSICK, S .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1958, 55 (04) :243-252
[18]   RESPONSE BIASES AND TRAIT DESCRIPTIVE ADJECTIVES [J].
JONES, RR ;
RORER, LG .
MULTIVARIATE BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH, 1973, 8 (03) :313-330
[19]   RESPONSE EFFECTS IN THE ELECTRONIC SURVEY [J].
KIESLER, S ;
SPROULL, LS .
PUBLIC OPINION QUARTERLY, 1986, 50 (03) :402-413
[20]  
MEERENS MR, 1970, PSYCHOL REP, V27, P802