Cochlear bearing loss is generally associated with a variety of deficits in the ability to analyze sounds, including reduced frequency selectivity. The complex interrelationships between the different deficits have made it difficult to assess the contribution of reduced frequency selectivity to the difficulties experienced by hearing-impaired people in understanding speech. To address this question, the effects of reduced frequency selectivity on the place representation of speech stimuli in the auditory system were simulated by ''smearing'' the spectra of the stimuli, using the overlap-add method. The smearing was designed to evoke excitation patterns in a normal ear that would resemble those evoked in an impaired ear using unsmeared stimuli. Several different types of smearing were used, simulating specific degrees of broadening and asymmetry of the auditory filter. Sentences in quiet and in speech-shaped noise were smeared and presented to normally hearing listeners in intelligibility tests. The results showed that the intelligibility of speech in quiet was hardly affected by spectral smearing, even for smearing that simulated auditory filters six times broader than normal. However, the intelligibility of speech in noise was adversely affected by the smearing, especially for large degrees of smearing and at a low speech-to-noise ratio (- 3 dB). Simulation of asymmetrical broadening of the lower side of the auditory filter had a greater effect than simulation of asymmetrical broadening of the upper side, suggesting that upward spread of masking may be particularly important.