COMPARISON OF YUZPE REGIMEN, DANAZOL, AND MIFEPRISTONE (RU486) IN ORAL POSTCOITAL CONTRACEPTION

被引:173
作者
WEBB, AMC
RUSSELL, J
ELSTEIN, M
机构
[1] UNIV HOSP S MANCHESTER, DEPT MED STAT, MANCHESTER M20 8LR, LANCS, ENGLAND
[2] UNIV HOSP S MANCHESTER, DEPT OBSTET & GYNAECOL, MANCHESTER M20 8LR, LANCS, ENGLAND
来源
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL | 1992年 / 305卷 / 6859期
关键词
D O I
10.1136/bmj.305.6859.927
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective-To compare the effectiveness and acceptability of three regimens of postcoital contraception. Design-Randomised group comparison of ethinyloestradiol 100 mug plus levonorgestrel 500 mug repeated after 12 hours (Yuzpe method); danazol 600 mg repeated after 12 hours; and mifepristone 600 mg single dose. Setting-Community family planning clinic. Subjects-616 consecutive women with regular cycles aged 16 to 45 years. Main outcome measures-Number of pregnancies, incidence of side effects, and timing of next period. Results-The raw pregnancy rates (with 95% confidence intervals) for the Yuzpe, danazol, and mifepristone groups were 2.62% (0.86% to 6.00%), 4.66% (2.15% to 8.67%), and 0% (0% to 1.87%) (respectively. Overall, these rates differed significantly (chi2=8.988, df=2; p=0.011). The differences between the mifepristone and Yuzpe groups and between the mifepristone and danazol groups were also significant. Side effects were more common and more severe in the Yuzpe group (133 women (70%)) than in either the danazol group (58 (30%)) or the mifepristone group (72 (37%)). The Yuzpe regimen tended to induce bleeding early but mifepristone prolonged the cycle. Three women bled more than seven days late in the Yuzpe group compared with 49 in the mifepristone group. Conclusions-Mifepristone was effective in reducing expected pregnancy rates and the Yuzpe method also had a clinical effect. Danazol had little or no effect. A further multicentre trial is needed.
引用
收藏
页码:927 / 931
页数:5
相关论文
共 20 条
[1]  
BARRETT JC, 1969, POP STUD-J DEMOG, V23, P455, DOI 10.1080/00324728.1969.10405297
[2]  
DHONT M, 1982, J OBSTET GYNAECOL, V2, P134
[3]   ETHINYL ESTRADIOL AND CONJUGATED ESTROGENS AS POST-COITAL CONTRACEPTIVES [J].
DIXON, GW ;
SCHLESSELMAN, JJ ;
ORY, HW ;
BLYE, RP .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1980, 244 (12) :1336-1339
[4]   POST-COITAL CONTRACEPTION - AN OVERVIEW OF PUBLISHED STUDIES [J].
FASOLI, M ;
PARAZZINI, F ;
CECCHETTI, G ;
LAVECCHIA, C .
CONTRACEPTION, 1989, 39 (04) :459-468
[5]  
GARDNER MJ, 1989, STATISTICS CONFIDENC
[6]   INTERCEPTION - POST-COITAL ESTROGENS IN 3016 WOMEN [J].
HASPELS, AA .
CONTRACEPTION, 1976, 14 (04) :375-381
[7]  
HERMANN WL, 1985, ANTIPROGESTIN STEROI, P199
[8]  
LAHTEENMAKI P, 1988, FERTIL STERIL, V50, P36
[9]  
NADLER RD, 1985, ANTIPROGESTIN STEROI, P169
[10]   POSTCOITAL CONTRACEPTION WITH DL-NORGESTREL ETHINYL ESTRADIOL COMBINATION - 6 YEARS EXPERIENCE IN A STUDENT MEDICAL CLINIC [J].
PERCIVALSMITH, RKL ;
ABERCROMBIE, B .
CONTRACEPTION, 1987, 36 (03) :287-293