Formal, systematic, and metasystematic operations with a balance-beam task series: A reply to Kallio's claim of no distinct systematic stage

被引:12
作者
Commons, ML
Goodheart, EA
Bresette, LM
Bauer, NF
Farrell, EW
McCarthy, KG
Danaher, DL
Richards, FA
Ellis, JB
OBrien, AM
Rodriguez, JA
Schraeder, D
机构
[1] Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Massachusetts Mental Health Center, 02115-6196, Massachusetts
关键词
postformal thought; formal-systematic-metasystematic thought; cognitive development;
D O I
10.1007/BF02265717
中图分类号
B844 [发展心理学(人类心理学)];
学科分类号
040202 ;
摘要
This reply discusses the measurement of formal, systematic, and metasystematic stages. Recent multidomain studies have shown disparate results and we suggest that these results could be attributed not to actual variations in adult development or the existence or non-existence of stage, but instead may reflect differences in methodology regarding task, domain, and scoring. Our study indicates that when tested in only one domain-balance beams and extensions of those tasks-participants who performed at the higher stage were also able to perform at the lower stages. These results also coincide with similar studies conducted.
引用
收藏
页码:193 / 199
页数:7
相关论文
共 34 条
[1]   COGNITIVE-DEVELOPMENT IN ADULTHOOD - 5TH STAGE [J].
ARLIN, PK .
DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1975, 11 (05) :602-606
[2]  
ARLIN PK, 1977, DEV PSYCHOL, V13, P247
[3]  
Commons M. L., 1984, FORMAL OPERATIONS, V1, P120
[4]   THE DEVELOPMENT OF HIERARCHICALLY COMPLEX EQUIVALENCE CLASSES [J].
COMMONS, ML ;
RODRIGUEZ, JA .
PSYCHOLOGICAL RECORD, 1993, 43 (04) :667-695
[5]   EQUAL ACCESS WITHOUT ESTABLISHING RELIGION - THE NECESSITY FOR ASSESSING SOCIAL PERSPECTIVE-TAKING SKILLS AND INSTITUTIONAL ATMOSPHERE [J].
COMMONS, ML ;
RODRIGUEZ, JA .
DEVELOPMENTAL REVIEW, 1990, 10 (04) :323-340
[6]   SYSTEMATIC AND METASYSTEMATIC REASONING - A CASE FOR LEVELS OF REASONING BEYOND PIAGETS STAGE OF FORMAL OPERATIONS [J].
COMMONS, ML ;
RICHARDS, FA ;
KUHN, D .
CHILD DEVELOPMENT, 1982, 53 (04) :1058-1069
[7]  
COMMONS ML, IN PRESS DEV REV
[8]  
COMMONS ML, 1989, ADULT DEV, V1, P33
[9]  
COMMONS ML, 1994, 8 S SOC RES AD DEV A
[10]  
COMMONS ML, 1990, ADULT DEV, V2, P205