The absorption spectra and emission spectra in aqueous solution of three types of phthalocyaninesulfonates of aluminum are compared: IA, a trisulfonate formed by sulfonation of aluminum phthalocyanine, shows no evidence for dimerization in water with changing pH or ionic strength. IIA, a tetrasulfonate prepared by metalation of the tetrasulfonated free base using Al(acac)3, when added to water immediately shows spectra characteristic of a "contact dimer". IIIA, a tetrasulfonate prepared by condensation of sulfophthalic acid around AlCl3, also shows dimer-like spectral changes, but they develop over 4 h. This "slow-forming dimer", like the "contact dimer", shows no emission but has a sharper red band. Comparison is made to similarly prepared phthalocyaninesulfonates of zinc: IZ, IIZ, IIIZ. Again, there is little dimer formation by IZ, although somewhat more than by IA. The zinc phthalocyaninetetrasulfonates, IIZ and IIIZ, show large amounts "contact dimer" but no "slow-forming dimer" spectrum, which is attributed to formation of a binuclear mu-oxo aluminum phthalocyaninetetrasulfonate.