OXYGEN ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF FOSSIL EQUID TOOTH AND BONE PHOSPHATE - AN ARCHIVE OF DIFFICULT INTERPRETATION

Variation in the concentration of the stable isotopes of hydrogen, oxygen and carbon have been tested in continental records as tools for quantitative or semi-quantitative paleoclimatological studies. Among the different methods, the potential use of oxygen isotopes in mammal bone and tooth phosphate has recently been recognized. Measurements carried out on fossil mammal bones of Holocene age and their paleoclimatological interpretation corresponded well with paleontological and paleobotanical records. In the case of considerably older fossils, diagenetic processes may change the primary oxygen isotopic composition of phosphate. Fossil horse bones and teeth (principally of the species Equus stenonis) were studied to ascertain how far back in time fossil mammal remains may be considered reliable material for paleoclimatological studies. The samples come from 13 different locations in southeastern Spain, their age ranging from Maspinian (late Pleistocene) to Middle Villafranchian (Pliocene). Apart from the variations of the delta(18)O(PO43-) values which may be related to climatic changes, it is apparent that the isotopic composition of bones and teeth from the same deposit are frequently rather different from one another. The isotopic differences range from a few tenths of one parts per thousand to several parts per thousand. This suggests a strong influence of taphonomy over the measured isotopic values of fossils in each deposit. Time can be considered neither the only variable nor the most important one responsible for the change of the primary isotopic composition of fossils. Under these conditions it is rather difficult to establish lower or upper limits for the age of fossils to be studied for reliable paleoclimatological information since the limits are directly related to taphonomic history. This, in turn, is related to local environmental conditions and not only to the age of fossils.