Populations of dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP) degrading bacteria were enumerated in Caribbean Sea waters using Most Probable Number (MPN) methodology. DMSP and 3-methiolpropionate (MMPA), an intermediate in the demethylation pathway of DMSP degradation, were used as enrichment substrates. Two metabolically distinct populations were obtained: DMSP cleavers, which produced dimethyl sulfide (DMS) from DMSP, and demethylators of DMSP, which produced 3-mercaptopropionate (MPA) and/or methanethiol (MSH) from DMSP or MMPA. Demethylating populations were distinct from DMS producers and formed 5 to 66 % of total DMSP degraders. DMSP utilizers comprized about 10 % of the total bacteria (MPNs on glucose-acetate) indicating the potential of DMSP as a carbon source for bacteria in the euphotic zone.