THE ANABOLIC EFFECT OF HUMAN PTH(1-34) ON BONE-FORMATION IS BLUNTED WHEN BONE-RESORPTION IS INHIBITED BY THE BISPHOSPHONATE TILUDRONATE - IS ACTIVATED RESORPTION A PREREQUISITE FOR THE IN-VIVO EFFECT OF PTH ON FORMATION IN A REMODELING SYSTEM

Parathyroid hormone (PTH) and its (1-34) fragment are stimulators of bone turnover that have an anabolic effect increasing trabecular bone mass when administered intermittently by daily subcutaneous injections, Its clinical use in osteoporosis, however, has been limited by the concomitant increased bone resorption and deleterious effect on cortical bone, To evaluate if a treatment combining PTH and a potent inhibitor of bone resorption would retain the anabolic effect of PTH without increasing bone resorption, we analyzed the effects of PTH (1-34) (500 IU/d) with or without the bisphosphonate tiludronate (1 mg/kg per day) for 3 months on biochemical and histological indices of bone turnover in old female sheep, an animal model which has a slow bone remodeling activity that resembles the one of elderly women, As expected, PTH (1-34) induced a significant increase of urinary pyridinoline and hydroxyproline (reflecting bone resorption), and of serum osteocalcin and alkaline phosphatase (reflecting bone formation), that were consistent with an increase of resorption and tetracycline-based formation of bone measured on iliac crest biopsy, In contrast, all biochemical and histological indices of bone turnover were decreased in sheep receiving tiludronate, a potent inhibitor of bone resorption. Surprisingly, in the combined therapy group, biochemical and histological indices of both resorption and formation did not differ from the control groups, Thus, the model of old sheep, which closely resembles the situation in old human, shows that the anabolic effect of PTH on bone is not maintained when PTH is coadministered with a bisphosphonate, in marked contrast to results noted in the growing rat, Because bisphosphonates are selective inhibitors of osteoclastic bone resorption that do not directly affect osteoblastic bone formation in vivo, these data suggest that the activation of bone resorption may be a prerequisite for the anabolic effect of PTH. Although tiludronate was the only bisphosphonate tested, our data also suggest that a combined PTH-bisphosphonate therapy is not a valid strategy for osteoporotic patients, Combination regimens of anabolic and antiresorptive agents may not be effective and should be tested in an appropriate animal model before clinical trials in osteoporotic patients are undertaken.