COENZYME-Q(10) WITH MULTIPLE VITAMINS IS GENERALLY INEFFECTIVE IN TREATMENT OF MITOCHONDRIAL DISEASE

被引:110
作者
MATTHEWS, PM
FORD, B
DANDURAND, RJ
EIDELMAN, DH
OCONNOR, D
SHERWIN, A
KARPATI, G
ANDERMANN, F
ARNOLD, DL
机构
[1] MONTREAL NEUROL HOSP & INST,3801 UNIV ST,MONTREAL H3A 2B4,QUEBEC,CANADA
[2] MCGILL UNIV,MEAKINS CHRISTIE LAB,MONTREAL H3A 2T5,QUEBEC,CANADA
[3] UNIV OXFORD,GENET LAB,OXFORD,ENGLAND
关键词
D O I
10.1212/WNL.43.5.884
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
We followed 16 patients with a variety of mitochondrial diseases over one to four periods of treatment (2 months each) with coenzyme Q10 plus vitamins K3 and C, riboflavin, thiamine, and niacin, using independent measures of oxidative metabolism to assess efficacy. There were large (>threefold) increases in serum coenzyme Q10 concentrations with treatment, but no measure of oxidative metabolism showed significant improvement with treatment for the group, nor did any individual patient show significant, reproducible, objective clinical improvement. The results suggest that coenzyme Q10 plus vitamin therapy does not significantly improve mitochondrial oxidative metabolism in patients with mitochondrial disease in general. Any clinical benefit that may follow from short-term administration appears slight.
引用
收藏
页码:884 / 890
页数:7
相关论文
共 32 条
[1]   TREATMENT OF MITOCHONDRIAL MYOPATHY DUE TO COMPLEX-III DEFICIENCY WITH VITAMINS K3 AND C - A P-31-NMR FOLLOW-UP-STUDY [J].
ARGOV, Z ;
BANK, WJ ;
MARIS, J ;
ELEFF, S ;
KENNAWAY, NG ;
OLSON, RE ;
CHANCE, B .
ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY, 1986, 19 (06) :598-602
[2]   METABOLIC RECOVERY AFTER EXERCISE AND THE ASSESSMENT OF MITOCHONDRIAL-FUNCTION INVIVO IN HUMAN SKELETAL-MUSCLE BY MEANS OF P-31 NMR [J].
ARNOLD, DL ;
MATTHEWS, PM ;
RADDA, GK .
MAGNETIC RESONANCE IN MEDICINE, 1984, 1 (03) :307-315
[3]  
ARTS WFM, 1983, LANCET, V2, P581
[4]   P-31 NMR-SPECTROSCOPY AND ERGOMETER EXERCISE TEST AS EVIDENCE FOR MUSCLE OXIDATIVE PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT WITH COENZYME-Q IN MITOCHONDRIAL MYOPATHIES [J].
BENDAHAN, D ;
DESNUELLE, C ;
VANUXEM, D ;
CONFORTGOUNY, S ;
FIGARELLABRANGER, D ;
PELLISSIER, JF ;
KOZAKRIBBENS, G ;
POUGET, J ;
SERRATRICE, G ;
COZZONE, PJ .
NEUROLOGY, 1992, 42 (06) :1203-1208
[5]   UBIDECARENONE IN THE TREATMENT OF MITOCHONDRIAL MYOPATHIES - A MULTICENTER DOUBLE-BLIND TRIAL [J].
BRESOLIN, N ;
DORIGUZZI, C ;
PONZETTO, C ;
ANGELINI, C ;
MORONI, I ;
CASTELLI, E ;
COSSUTTA, E ;
BINDA, A ;
GALLANTI, A ;
GABELLINI, S ;
PICCOLO, G ;
MARTINUZZI, A ;
CIAFALONI, E ;
ARNAUDO, E ;
LICIARDELLO, L ;
CARENZI, A ;
SCARLATO, G .
JOURNAL OF THE NEUROLOGICAL SCIENCES, 1990, 100 (1-2) :70-78
[6]   CLINICAL AND BIOCHEMICAL CORRELATIONS IN MITOCHONDRIAL MYOPATHIES TREATED WITH COENZYME-Q10 [J].
BRESOLIN, N ;
BET, L ;
BINDA, A ;
MOGGIO, M ;
COMI, G ;
NADOR, F ;
FERRANTE, C ;
CARENZI, A ;
SCARLATO, G .
NEUROLOGY, 1988, 38 (06) :892-899
[7]  
DANDURAND R J, 1991, American Review of Respiratory Disease, V143, pA172
[8]   RIBOFLAVIN-RESPONSIVE LIPID-STORAGE MYOPATHY AND GLUTARIC ACIDURIA TYPE-II OF EARLY ADULT ONSET [J].
DEVISSER, M ;
SCHOLTE, HR ;
SCHUTGENS, RBH ;
BOLHUIS, PA ;
LUYTHOUWEN, IEM ;
VAANDRAGERVERDUIN, MHM ;
VEDER, HA ;
OEY, PL .
NEUROLOGY, 1986, 36 (03) :367-372
[9]   MITOCHONDRIAL MYOPATHIES [J].
DIMAURO, S ;
BONILLA, E ;
ZEVIANI, M ;
NAKAGAWA, M ;
DEVIVO, DC .
ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY, 1985, 17 (06) :521-538
[10]  
DIONISIO P, 1991, Neurology, V41, P209