PREREGISTRATION HOUSE OFFICERS IN 8 ENGLISH REGIONS - SURVEY OF QUALITY OF TRAINING

被引:24
作者
GILLARD, JH
DENT, THS
AARONS, EJ
SMYTHPIGOTT, PJ
NICHOLLS, MWN
机构
[1] FULBOURNE HOSP,DEPT PUBL HLTH MED,CAMBRIDGE CB1 5EF,ENGLAND
[2] JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV HOSP,DIV NEURORADIOL,BALTIMORE,MD 21287
[3] MONSALL HOSP,MANCHESTER M10 8WR,ENGLAND
[4] BRITISH POSTGRAD MED FEDERAT,LONDON WC1N 3EJ,ENGLAND
[5] JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV HOSP,DEPT NEUROL,BALTIMORE,MD 21287
[6] JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV,SCH MED,BALTIMORE,MD 21287
关键词
D O I
10.1136/bmj.307.6913.1180
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective-To assess the quality of preregistration house officer training in eight English regions. Design-Postal questionnaire. Setting-Thames, East Anglian, Mersey, Northern, and Wessex regions. Participants-1670 preregistration house officers. Main outcome measures-Education, hours of work, workload, conditions of work, and attitudes to job and medicine as a career. Results-Response rate was 69% (1146 replies). Most house officers had attended induction courses (1036/1129 (92%)); 74% (757/1024) found them satisfactory. The proportions who had never received adequate guidance on how to break bad news and how to control pain were 59% (670/1135) and 56% (634/1136) respectively. There was much variation between regions. Overall, 65% (736/1138) reported confidence in performing cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Most respondents (95% (1089/1142)) worked an on call rota, 3% (36) a partial shift, and 0.6% (seven) a full shift; 19% (202) were on duty for average weekly hours that exceeded the targets for 1 April 1993. House officers had a median of 20 patients under their care and clerked a median of 10 emergency cases, six routine cases, and two day cases a week. Over half (690/1128 (61%)) could not obtain hot food after 8 pm, 20% (223/1095) did not always have clean sheets available in their on call room, and 45% (462/1036) did not consider the protection of staff against violence to be adequate at their hospital. The most important problems with the preregistration year were inappropriate or non-medical tasks (ranked first by 360 respondents), hours of work (359), and pay for out of hours work (167). Overall 57% (646/1125) would encourage a friend to apply for their post, but only 24% (266/1112) would encourage a friend to take up medicine and 44% (494/1112) would discourage the idea. Conclusions-House officers' training is deficient in important respects, with inappropriate tasks and heavy clinical workloads impeding the provision of proper education.
引用
收藏
页码:1180 / 1184
页数:5
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]  
CALMAN KC, 1992, MAKING DOCTOR MED ED
[2]   THE PRE-REGISTRATION HOUSE APPOINTMENT - A SURVEY IN MANCHESTER [J].
CHRISTIE, RAS .
MEDICAL EDUCATION, 1980, 14 (03) :210-213
[3]   PREREGISTRATION HOUSE OFFICERS IN THE 4 THAMES REGIONS .1. SURVEY OF EDUCATION AND WORKLOAD [J].
DENT, THS ;
GILLARD, JH ;
AARONS, EJ ;
CRIMLISK, HL ;
SMYTHPIGOTT, PJ .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1990, 300 (6726) :713-716
[4]   QUALITY OF PRESCRIBING OF INTRAVENOUS ANTIBIOTICS IN A DISTRICT GENERAL-HOSPITAL [J].
DENTON, M ;
MORGAN, MS ;
WHITE, RR .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1991, 302 (6772) :327-328
[5]  
DOWIE R, 1991, PATTERNS HOSPITAL ME
[6]  
DOWLING S, 1992, DOCTORS MAKING EXPER
[7]   PREREGISTRATION HOUSE OFFICERS IN THE THAMES REGIONS - CHANGES IN QUALITY OF TRAINING AFTER 4 YEARS [J].
GILLARD, JH ;
DENT, THS ;
AARONS, EJ ;
CRIMLISK, HL ;
SMYTHPIGOTT, PJ ;
NICHOLLS, MWN .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1993, 307 (6913) :1176-1179
[8]   SENIOR HOUSE OFFICERS AND THEIR TRAINING .1. PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS AND PROFESSIONAL CIRCUMSTANCES [J].
GRANT, J ;
MARSDEN, P ;
KING, RC .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1989, 299 (6710) :1263-1265
[9]   MEDICAL-EDUCATION .7. THE PREREGISTRATION YEAR [J].
LOWRY, S .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1993, 306 (6871) :196-198
[10]  
MCMANUS IC, 1977, LANCET, V1, P413