CARDIAC REHABILITATION IN SWITZERLAND - EFFICACY OF THE RESIDENTIAL APPROACH FOLLOWING BYPASS-SURGERY

Background: The traditional central European approach to cardiac rehabilitation involves sending patients to an idyllic setting, where they reside for a specified period following a cardiac event. Favorable results have been demonstrated using this approach in Germany, but to our knowledge no data have been reported from Switzerland, where these programs tend to be short (4 weeks) and exercise training is concentrated (2 h daily, 6 days per week). Methods and Results: Seventeen patients (aged 58 +/- 6 years) who resided in a rehabilitation center for 4 weeks were compared with 11 patients (aged 54 +/- 7 years) given usual community care beginning approximately 6 weeks after coronary artery bypass surgery (CABS). Exercise training consisted of 1 h of group walking twice daily, with the intensity stratified into 4 levels based on clinical status and initial exercise capacity. All patients underwent pulmonary function testing and maximal ramp exercise testing on a cycle ergometer with continuous ventilatory gas exchange and lactate analysis before and after the study period. Patients receiving beta-blockers and those with cardiomyopathy or valvular heart disease were excluded. Medication status was not changed during the study period. Although maximal oxygen uptake increased by approximately 12 percent within both groups, the change was not significant between groups. Analysis of variance demonstrated that mean lactate levels were reduced throughout exercise within both groups (p<0.001); however, there were no differences between groups. Oxygen uptake at the lactate threshold was not different in either group after the study period. Conclusion: Similar changes occur in the functional status of post-CABS patients regardless of their participation in the short but concentrated rehabilitation programs common in Switzerland, suggesting that these programs either begin too soon after CABS or are too short to achieve training benefits.