Sulfenylation of indole using a sulfenyl chloride occurs initially at the 3-position of the ring, leading to a 3-indolyl sulfide. When an excess of sulfenyl chloride is used, a second sulfide group is introduced at the 2-position, and an indolyl 2,3-bis-sulfide results. We have demonstrated that this second sulfenylation occurs not by direct introduction of the second sulfide at the 2-position but via initial formation of an indolenium 3,3-bis-sulfide intermediate, followed by migration of one of the sulfide groups to the 2-position. This was achieved by the isolation of two examples of 3H-indole 3,3-bissulfides and by subsequent demonstration that they rearrange to the indolyl 2,3-bis-sulfides by treatment with sulfenyl halides.