A comparison of proliferation indices in human anterior pituitary adenomas using formalin-fixed tissue and in vitro cell culture

The authors compared detection methods for cell proliferation in human anterior pituitary adenomas using histological sections and dispersed cell culture. After tumor cells had been grown for 4 days in dispersed culture, bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR), proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), and Ki-67 were compared by double immunostaining and contrasted with single staining of PCNA and Ki-67 indices in the corresponding histological sections from 12 human pituitary adenomas. In vitro, the BUdR labeling index was positive in six of 12 tumors (range < 0.1-5.1%), 10 of 12 tumors were PCNA-positive (range < 0.1-100%), and Ki-67 was positive in 10 of 12 adenomas (range < 0.1-8%). In vitro, BUdR and Ki-67 gave similar proliferative indices for 10 of 12 adenomas. In vivo, the PCNA labeling index was positive in 12 of 12 adenomas (range 0.9-95% and Ki-67 was positive in 11 of 12 adenomas (range < 0.1-2%). Tumors with a labeling index less than 0.1% were considered to be negative for proliferation. High PCNA values were found in vitro and in vivo, whereas Ki-67 labeling indices were similar in vitro and in vivo for nine of 12 adenomas. It is concluded that Ki-67 proliferative indices in vivo reflect those found in vitro, at least after 4 days in dispersed culture, but that PCNA overestimates pituitary adenoma proliferation in histological sections as well as in dispersed culture.