Tartrate-resistant acid phosphate activity as osteoclastic marker: Sensitivity of cytochemical assessment and serum assay in comparison with standardized osteoclast histomorphometry

Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) activity is regarded as an important cytochemical marker of osteoclasts; its concentration in serum is utilized as a biochemical marker of osteoclast function and degree of bone resorption. This study was carried out to assess the sensitivity of TRAP activity both as a cytochemical marker in histological sections and as a biochemical marker in serum in comparison with the standardized histomorphometric variables of osteoclasts. To this end we investigated 24 patients (21 women, 3 men; 60 +/- 17 years of age) affected with various metabolic bone diseases. Osteoclast surface (OcS/BS) and osteoclast number (OcN/BS) were evaluated by standardized histomorphometry in iliac crest biopsies. On the basis of TRAP cytochemical activity, TRAP-positive osteoclast surface (TRAP+OcS/BS) and number (TRAP+OcN/BS) were measured. TRAP-positive cells adjacent to bone and showing one nucleus or no nuclei at all in the plane of section were included in the counts as osteoclasts. Serum TRAP activity was determined by spectrophotometric assay. Values of OcS/BS and OcN/BS were much lower than those of TRAP+OcS/BS (-50%) and TRAP+OcN/BS (-60%), respectively. Correlations between OcS/BS and TRAP+OcS/BS, and between OcN/BS and TRAPS OcN/BS, were highly significant. Serum TRAP was significantly correlated with OcS/BS, OcN/BS, and TRAP+OcN/BS. These correlations, however, were rather low. Moreover, serum TRAP did not correlate with TRAP+OcS/BS. From these results, the conclusion can be drawn that while TRAP activity is confirmed as a valid cytochemical marker for identification of osteoclasts, serum TRAP activity is an osteoclastic marker of weak sensitivity. This may be due to known factors, such as synthesis of the enzyme not being unique to osteoclasts, enzyme instability, and the presence of inhibitors in serum. Mononucleated osteoclasts do not significantly influence the serum enzyme levels.