Omega-3 fatty acids and low carbohydrate diet for maintenance of remission in Crohn's disease - A randomized controlled multicenter trial

被引:171
作者
LorenzMeyer, H
Bauer, P
Nicolay, C
Schulz, B
Purrmann, J
Fleig, WE
Scheurlen, C
Koop, I
Pudel, V
Carr, L
Scheurlen, M
Daiss, W
Decker, M
Jores, R
Hoffmann, R
Weigand, K
LehnenHoltum, V
Kruis, W
Rommele, U
Schroter, E
Schomerus, H
Linn, T
Kestler, X
Warm, K
Schmidt, C
Junge, U
Huk, L
Sommer, H
Auer, IO
Gladisch, R
Gutschmidt, S
Lutz, W
Martini, GA
Malchow, H
机构
[1] UNIV KLIN MUNCHEN GROSSHADERN, MUNICH, GERMANY
[2] UNIV KLIN TUBINGEN, TUBINGEN, GERMANY
[3] UNIV KLIN ERLANGEN, ERLANGEN, GERMANY
[4] UNIV KLIN WURZBURG, WURZBURG, GERMANY
[5] KRANKENHAUS ESSLINGEN, ESSLINGEN, GERMANY
[6] UNIV KLIN FRANKFURT, FRANKFURT, GERMANY
[7] UNIV KLIN KOLN, COLOGNE, GERMANY
[8] MED KLIN ROTENBURG WUMME 2, ROTENBURG, GERMANY
[9] UNIV KLIN GIESSEN, GIESSEN, GERMANY
[10] KLINIKUM RECHTS ISAR MUNCHEN, MUNICH, GERMANY
[11] VITAISKLIN BAD HERSFELD, BAD HERSFELD, GERMANY
[12] UNIV KLIN BONN, BONN, GERMANY
[13] STADT KRANKENHAUS BIELEFED, BIELEFELD, GERMANY
[14] MED KLIN DORTMUND, DORTMUND, GERMANY
[15] KREISKRANKENHAUS HIEDENHEIM, HEIDENHEIM, GERMANY
[16] JULIUS SPITAL WURZBURG, WURZBURG, GERMANY
[17] KLINIKUM MANNHEIM, MANNHEIM, GERMANY
[18] FACHKLIN FRANK SAALE BAD NEUSTADT, Bad Neustadt an der Saale, GERMANY
[19] UNIV GOTTINGEN, INST ERNAHRUNG, D-3400 GOTTINGEN, GERMANY
[20] UNIV VIENNA, INST MED STATIST, VIENNA, AUSTRIA
[21] STADT KRANKENHAUS MUTLANGEN, MUTLANGEN, GERMANY
[22] STADT KRANKENHAUS HEILBRONN, HEILBRONN, GERMANY
[23] UNIV KLIN MARBURG, MARBURG, GERMANY
[24] STADT KLIN LEVERKUSEN, LEVERKUSEN, GERMANY
关键词
Crohn's disease; low carbohydrate diet; maintenance of remission; omega-3 fatty acids; randomized controlled multicenter trial;
D O I
10.3109/00365529609010352
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: There is no established therapy for maintaining remission in patients with Crohn's disease. Following different suggestions from the literature, two potential interventions for maintaining remission were tested against placebo, using either 5 g/day of a highly concentrated omega-3 fatty acid compound or a carbohydrate-reduced diet (84 g/day). Methods: A total of 204 patients were recruited after they had had an acute relapse. After remission (CDAI less than or equal to 150) was attained with steroid therapy, patients were randomized to receive either omega-3 fatty acids (n = 70), placebo (n = 65), or diet (n = 69). Low-dose prednisolone was given to all patients for the first 8 weeks of intervention, CDAI and an acute-phase protein (CRP) were used as criteria for a relapse. Results: The proportion of patients without relapse within a year were similar in the placebo and active treatment group (intention-to-treat analysis: placebo, 30%; active treatment, 30%; protocol-adhering patients, 29% versus 28%). Patients did gain benefit (53%; p = 0.023) for as long as they maintained the diet. However, intention-to-treat analysis (diet group, 40%) did not show a noticeable difference when compared with placebo. Conclusions: Omega-3 fatty acids did not show an effect on extending the remission in Crohn's disease. For the diet patients the question remains whether the noncompliant patients dropped out early because they sensed a relapse approaching or whether their condition deteriorated because they failed to comply with the diet.
引用
收藏
页码:778 / 785
页数:8
相关论文
共 27 条
[1]  
BEST WR, 1976, GASTROENTEROLOGY, V70, P439
[2]  
BRANDES JW, 1981, Z GASTROENTEROL, V19, P1
[3]  
EMPEY LR, 1989, GASTROENTEROLOGY, V96, pA83
[4]   THE EFFECT OF DIETARY SUPPLEMENTATION WITH N-3 POLY-UNSATURATED FATTY-ACIDS ON THE SYNTHESIS OF INTERLEUKIN-1 AND TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR BY MONONUCLEAR-CELLS [J].
ENDRES, S ;
GHORBANI, R ;
KELLEY, VE ;
GEORGILIS, K ;
LONNEMANN, G ;
VANDERMEER, JWM ;
CANNON, JG ;
ROGERS, TS ;
KLEMPNER, MS ;
WEBER, PC ;
SCHAEFER, EJ ;
WOLFF, SM ;
DINARELLO, CA .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1989, 320 (05) :265-271
[5]   PLASMA POLYUNSATURATED FATTY-ACID PATTERN IN ACTIVE INFLAMMATORY BOWEL-DISEASE [J].
ESTEVECOMAS, M ;
RAMIREZ, M ;
FERNANDEZBANARES, F ;
ABADLACRUZ, A ;
GIL, A ;
CABRE, E ;
GONZALEZHUIX, F ;
MORENO, J ;
HUMBERT, P ;
GUILERA, M ;
BOIX, J ;
GASSULL, MA .
GUT, 1992, 33 (10) :1365-1369
[6]  
GREENFIELD SM, 1993, ALIMENT PHARM THERAP, V7, P159
[7]   TREATMENT OF CROHNS-DISEASE WITH AN UNREFINED-CARBOHYDRATE, FIBER-RICH DIET [J].
HEATON, KW ;
THORNTON, JR ;
EMMETT, PM .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1979, 2 (6193) :764-766
[8]  
JONES VA, 1985, LANCET, V2, P177
[9]   SMOKING AND SUGAR INTAKE ARE SEPARATE BUT INTERACTIVE RISK-FACTORS IN CROHNS-DISEASE [J].
KATSCHINSKI, B ;
LOGAN, RFA ;
EDMOND, M ;
LANGMAN, MJS .
GUT, 1988, 29 (09) :1202-1206
[10]   INVIVO PROFILES OF EICOSANOIDS IN ULCERATIVE-COLITIS, CROHNS COLITIS, AND CLOSTRIDIUM-DIFFICILE COLITIS [J].
LAURITSEN, K ;
LAURSEN, LS ;
BUKHAVE, K ;
RASKMADSEN, J .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1988, 95 (01) :11-17