Blind analysis in nuclear and particle physics

被引:73
作者
Klein, JR [1 ]
Roodman, A
机构
[1] Univ Texas, Dept Phys, Austin, TX 78712 USA
[2] Stanford Univ, Stanford Linear Accelerator Ctr, Stanford, CA 94309 USA
关键词
blind analysis; experimenter's bias; experimental methods; systematic errors;
D O I
10.1146/annurev.nucl.55.090704.151521
中图分类号
O57 [原子核物理学、高能物理学];
学科分类号
070202 ;
摘要
During the past decade, blind analysis has become a widely used tool in nuclear and particle physics measurements. A blind analysis avoids the possibility of experimenters biasing their result toward their own preconceptions by preventing them from knowing the answer until the analysis is complete. There is at least circumstantial evidence that such a bias has affected past measurements, and as experiments have become costlier and more difficult and hence harder to reproduce, the possibility of bias has become a more important issue than in the past. We describe here the motivations for performing a blind analysis, and give several modern examples of successful blind analysis strategies.
引用
收藏
页码:141 / 163
页数:27
相关论文
共 59 条
[1]   Analysis of LIGO data for gravitational waves from binary neutron stars -: art. no. 122001 [J].
Abbott, B ;
Abbott, R ;
Adhikari, R ;
Ageev, A ;
Allen, B ;
Amin, R ;
Anderson, SB ;
Anderson, WG ;
Araya, M ;
Armandula, H ;
Asiri, F ;
Aufmuth, P ;
Aulbert, C ;
Babak, S ;
Balasubramanian, R ;
Ballmer, S ;
Barish, BC ;
Barker, D ;
Barker-Patton, C ;
Barnes, M ;
Barr, B ;
Barton, MA ;
Bayer, K ;
Beausoleil, R ;
Belczynski, K ;
Bennett, R ;
Berukoff, SJ ;
Betzwieser, J ;
Bhawal, B ;
Bilenko, IA ;
Billingsley, G ;
Black, E ;
Blackburn, K ;
Bland-Weaver, B ;
Bochner, B ;
Bogue, L ;
Bork, R ;
Bose, S ;
Brady, PR ;
Braginsky, VB ;
Brau, JE ;
Brown, DA ;
Brozek, S ;
Bullington, A ;
Buonanno, A ;
Burgess, R ;
Busby, D ;
Butler, WE ;
Byer, RL ;
Cadonati, L .
PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2004, 69 (12)
[2]   Further search for the decay K+→π+ν(ν)over-bar in the momentum region P<195 MeV/c -: art. no. 037102 [J].
Adler, S ;
Aoki, M ;
Ardebili, M ;
Atiya, MS ;
Bazarko, AO ;
Bergbusch, PC ;
Bhuyan, B ;
Blackmore, EW ;
Bryman, DA ;
Chiang, IH ;
Convery, MR ;
Diwan, MV ;
Frank, JS ;
Haggerty, JS ;
Inagaki, T ;
Ito, MM ;
Jain, V ;
Jaffe, DE ;
Kabe, S ;
Kazumori, M ;
Kettell, SH ;
Kitching, P ;
Kobayashi, M ;
Komatsubara, TK ;
Konaka, A ;
Kuno, Y ;
Kuriki, M ;
Kycia, TF ;
Li, KK ;
Littenberg, LS ;
Macdonald, JA ;
McPherson, RA ;
Meyers, PD ;
Mildenberger, J ;
Muramatsu, N ;
Nakano, T ;
Ng, C ;
Ng, S ;
Numao, T ;
Otomo, A ;
Poutissou, JM ;
Poutissou, R ;
Redlinger, G ;
Sasaki, T ;
Sato, T ;
Shinkawa, T ;
Shoemaker, FC ;
Smith, AJS ;
Soluk, R ;
Stone, JR .
PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2004, 70 (03) :037102-1
[3]  
AGUILARBENITEZ M, 1986, PHYS LETT B, V170, P1
[4]   Measurement of the rate of νe+d →p+p+e- interactions produced by 8B solar neutrinos at the sudbury neutrino observatory -: art. no. 071301 [J].
Ahmad, QR ;
Allen, RC ;
Andersen, TC ;
Anglin, JD ;
Bühler, G ;
Barton, JC ;
Beier, EW ;
Bercovitch, M ;
Bigu, J ;
Biller, S ;
Black, RA ;
Blevis, I ;
Boardman, RJ ;
Boger, J ;
Bonvin, E ;
Boulay, MG ;
Bowler, MG ;
Bowles, TJ ;
Brice, SJ ;
Browne, MC ;
Bullard, TV ;
Burritt, TH ;
Cameron, K ;
Cameron, J ;
Chan, YD ;
Chen, M ;
Chen, HH ;
Chen, X ;
Chon, MC ;
Cleveland, BT ;
Clifford, ETH ;
Cowan, JHM ;
Cowen, DF ;
Cox, GA ;
Dai, Y ;
Dai, X ;
Dalnoki-Veress, F ;
Davidson, WF ;
Doe, PJ ;
Doucas, G ;
Dragowsky, MR ;
Duba, CA ;
Duncan, FA ;
Dunmore, J ;
Earle, ED ;
Elliott, SR ;
Evans, HC ;
Ewan, GT ;
Farine, J ;
Fergani, H .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2001, 87 (07) :71301-1
[5]   Measurement of the total active 8B solar neutrino flux at the sudbury neutrino observatory with enhanced neutral current sensitivity -: art. no. 181301 [J].
Ahmed, SN ;
Anthony, AE ;
Beier, EW ;
Bellerive, A ;
Biller, SD ;
Boger, J ;
Boulay, MG ;
Bowler, MG ;
Bowles, TJ ;
Brice, SJ ;
Bullard, TV ;
Chan, YD ;
Chen, M ;
Chen, X ;
Cleveland, BT ;
Cox, GA ;
Dai, X ;
Dalnoki-Veress, F ;
Doe, PJ ;
Dosanjh, RS ;
Doucas, G ;
Dragowsky, MR ;
Duba, CA ;
Duncan, FA ;
Dunford, M ;
Dunmore, JA ;
Earle, ED ;
Elliott, SR ;
Evans, HC ;
Ewan, GT ;
Farine, J ;
Fergani, H ;
Fleurot, F ;
Formaggio, JA ;
Fowler, MM ;
Frame, K ;
Fulsom, BG ;
Gagnon, N ;
Graham, K ;
Grant, DR ;
Hahn, RL ;
Hall, JC ;
Hallin, AL ;
Hallman, ED ;
Hamer, AS ;
Handler, WB ;
Hargrove, CK ;
Harvey, PJ ;
Hazama, R ;
Heeger, KM .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2004, 92 (18) :181301-1
[6]   Observation of direct CP violation in KS,L → ππ decays [J].
Alavi-Harati, A ;
Albuquerque, IF ;
Alexopoulos, T ;
Arenton, M ;
Arisaka, K ;
Averitte, S ;
Barker, AR ;
Bellantoni, L ;
Bellavance, A ;
Belz, J ;
Ben-David, R ;
Bergman, DR ;
Blucher, E ;
Bock, GJ ;
Bown, C ;
Bright, S ;
Cheu, E ;
Childress, S ;
Coleman, R ;
Corcoran, MD ;
Corti, G ;
Cox, B ;
Crisler, MB ;
Erwin, AR ;
Ford, R ;
Glazov, A ;
Golossanov, A ;
Graham, G ;
Graham, J ;
Hagan, K ;
Halkiadakis, E ;
Hanagaki, K ;
Hidaka, S ;
Hsiung, YB ;
Jejer, V ;
Jennings, J ;
Jensen, DA ;
Kessler, R ;
Kobrak, HGE ;
LaDue, J ;
Lath, A ;
Ledovskoy, A ;
McBride, PL ;
McManus, AP ;
Mikelsons, P ;
Monnier, E ;
Nakaya, T ;
Nauenberg, U ;
Nelson, KS ;
Nguyen, H .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 1999, 83 (01) :22-27
[7]   Improved branching ratio measurement for the decay K0L → μ+μ- [J].
Ambrose, D ;
Arroyo, C ;
Bachman, M ;
Connor, D ;
Eckhause, M ;
Graessle, S ;
Hancock, AD ;
Hartman, K ;
Hebert, M ;
Hoff, CH ;
Hoffmann, GW ;
Irwin, GM ;
Kane, JR ;
Kanematsu, N ;
Kuang, Y ;
Lang, K ;
Lee, R ;
Martin, RD ;
McDonough, J ;
Milder, A ;
Molzon, WR ;
Pommot-Maia, M ;
Riley, PJ ;
Ritchie, JL ;
Rubin, PD ;
Vassilakopoulos, VI ;
Welsh, RE ;
Wojcicki, SG .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2000, 84 (07) :1389-1392
[8]   REVIEW OF PARTICLE PROPERTIES [J].
不详 .
REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS, 1984, 56 (02) :S1-S304
[9]  
[Anonymous], 1942, REP PROG PHYS
[10]   IMPROVED UPPER LIMIT ON THE BRANCHING RATIO B(KL(0)-]MU+/-E+/-) [J].
ARISAKA, K ;
AUERBACH, LB ;
AXELROD, S ;
BELZ, J ;
BIERY, KA ;
BUCHHOLZ, P ;
CHAPMAN, MD ;
COUSINS, RD ;
DIWAN, MV ;
ECKHAUSE, M ;
GINKEL, JF ;
GUSS, C ;
HANCOCK, AD ;
HEINSON, AP ;
HIGHLAND, VL ;
HOFFMANN, GW ;
HORVATH, J ;
IRWIN, GM ;
JOYCE, D ;
KAARSBERG, T ;
KANE, JR ;
KENNEY, CJ ;
KETTELL, SH ;
KINNISON, WW ;
KNIBBE, P ;
KONIGSBERG, J ;
KUANG, Y ;
LANG, K ;
LEE, DM ;
MARGULIES, J ;
MATHIAZHAGAN, C ;
MCFARLANE, WK ;
MCKEE, RJ ;
MELESE, P ;
MILNER, EC ;
MOLZON, WR ;
OUIMETTE, DA ;
RILEY, PJ ;
RITCHIE, JL ;
RUBIN, P ;
SANDERS, GH ;
SCHWARTZ, AJ ;
SIVERTZ, M ;
SLATER, WE ;
URHEIM, J ;
VULCAN, WF ;
WAGNER, DL ;
WELSH, RE ;
WHYLEY, RJ ;
WINTER, RG .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 1993, 70 (08) :1049-1052