Radiation therapy results for patients undergoing inappropriate surgery in the presence of invasive cervical carcinoma

Total vaginal or abdominal hysterectomy was considered an inadequate treatment method for invasive uterine cervix cancer. Usually the procedure was inadvertently performed on patients who were thought preoperatively to have benign or premalignant conditions. Between 1985 and 1993, 64 patients undergoing hysterectomy in the presence of invasive cervical cancer were treated with external radiation therapy and/or intracavitary radiotherapy. Preoperative diagnoses were carcinoma in situ (36), severe dysplasia (2), and early invasive cancer (14), and others were benign disease. Overall 5-year survival and relapse-free survival rates were 75.8 and 77.5%, respectively. For patients in retrospective stage IA, IB, and IIB (gross residual after surgery), overall 5-year survival rates were 90.9, 88.8, and 27.9%, respectively. Thirteen patients developed treatment failure; most of them (10/13) were patients with gross residual disease. Patients with early invasive cervical cancer (stage IA) had no treatment-related failure. Prognostic factors affecting survival by univariate analysis were retrospective stage (P = 0.0000) and preoperative diagnosis (P = 0.0021). Tumor histology was marginally significant factor (P = 0.0938). By multivariate analysis, only retrospective stage was significant prognostic factor (P = 0.0001). Adjuvant radiotherapy appears to be an effective treatment method for patients with presumed stage IA and IB after inadvertent hysterectomy. Survival for patients with gross disease remaining after inappropriate hysterectomy is poor. So, early cancer detection and proper management with precise pretreatment staging is necessary to avoid inadherent hysterectomy, especially in cases of gross residual disease. (C) 1997 Academic Press.