Spermatogonial survival after grafting human testicular tissue to immunodeficient mice

BACKGROUND: The xenografting of pre-pubertal human testicular tissue to an immunodeficient mouse is a theoretical strategy for restoring fertility in childhood cancer patients, while circumventing the risk of malignant recurrence. This study aimed at comparing the grafting of pre-pubertal and adult murine testicular tissue, as well as that of human adult testicular tissue, to two immunodeficient recipients, i.e. Swiss Nude mice and SCID-NOD mice. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this study, we evaluated the survival of pre-pubertal and adult murine testicular tissues, and that of adult human testicular tissue after subcutaneous grafting to immunodeficient mice. RESULTS: After allografting pre-pubertal testicular tissue pieces, meiotic cells were observed in 69.1% of the grafts, while complete spermatogenesis was observed in 30.9%. All grafts of adult murine testicular tissue and 59.5% of the adult human testicular grafts showed sclerosis. However, in 21.6% of the adult human testicular grafts, spermatogonia were still observed, with increasing sclerosis in time. No significant differences were observed between the two mouse models under evaluation. CONCLUSION: After xenografting human adult testicular tissue to a recipient mouse, spermatogonia were maintained over a period of > 195 days. However, in order to prove xenografting as a method for external germ line storage, the transplants should have a more immature developmental stage. Moreover, not only the developmental status of the tissue at the time-point of grafting, but also the structural organisation of the seminiferous epithelium, might influence the development of the testicular tissue.