Intragenomic nucleotide polymorphism among small subunit (18s) rdna paralogs in the diatom genus Skeletonema (Bacillariophyta)

Morphological features of the siliceous cell wall traditionally have been used to diagnose and classify species of diatoms, though an increasing number of studies distinguish new species, in part, by phylogenetic analysis of rDNA sequences. Intragenomic sequence variation is common among the hundreds to thousands of rDNA cistrons present within a genome, and this variation has strong potential to obscure species boundaries based on rDNA sequences. We screened six Skeletonema culture strains for intragenomic nucleotide polymorphisms in the small subunit (SSU) rDNA gene and found that all strains had polymorphic sites, with proportions ranging from 0.57% to 1.81%. In all cases, transitions accounted for more than 70% of nucleotide differences at polymorphic sites. Polymorphic sites were split nearly evenly in the SSU rRNA molecule between the base-paired regions of helices (52%) and the unpaired regions of loops and bulges (48%). Phylogenetic analysis showed that SSU rDNA genotypes were monophyletic for two of the six culture strains examined. Genotypes from the other four culture strains either showed little or no phylogenetic structure compared with genotypes of other conspecific culture strains or had phylogenetic structure that was incongruent with existing species boundaries. Moderate to strong support for monophyly was recovered for four of the seven species included in the analysis. Phylogenetic results combined with the low sequence divergence of SSU rDNA genotypes within species suggest that concerted evolution has not proceeded to completion in these species and/or that the rate at which variation is being generated exceeds the rate at which concerted evolution is expunging variation.