Dual effects of Sprouty1 on TCR signaling depending on the differentiation state of the T cell

Sprouty (Spry) is known to be a negative feedback inhibitor of growth factor receptor signaling through inhibition of the Ras/MAPK pathway. Several groups, however, have reported a positive role for Spry involving sequestration of the inhibitory protein c-Cbl. Thus, Spry may have various functions in the regulation of receptor-mediated signaling depending on the context. In the immune system, the function of Spry is unknown. In this study, we investigated the role of Spry1 in T cell activation. Spry1, among the four mammalian homologs, was specifically induced by TCR signaling of CD4(+) murine T cells. In fully differentiated Th1 clones, overexpressed Spry1 inhibited TCR signaling and decreased IL-2 production while reducing expression with specific siRNA transfection had the opposite effect, increasing IL-2 production. In contrast, in naive T cells, Spry1 overexpression enhanced TCR signaling, and increased proliferation and IL-2 production, while siRNA transfection again had the opposite effect, reducing IL-2 production following activation. The enhancing effect in naive cells was abrogated by preactivation of the T cells with Ag and APC, indicating that the history of exposure to Ag is correlated with a hierarchy of T cell responsiveness to Spry1. Furthermore, both the NF-AT and MAPK pathways were influenced by Spry1, implying a different molecular mechanism from that for growth factor receptor signaling. Thus, Spry1 uses a novel mechanism to bring about differential effects on TCR signaling through the same receptor, depending on the differentiation state of the T cell.