Nonstationarity broadening reduction in pulsed Doppler spectrum measurements using time-frequency estimators

The spectral width of Doppler signals is used as measure of lesion-induced flow disturbance. Its estimation accuracy is compromised using the conventional short-term Fourier transform (STFT) since this method implicitly assumes signal stationarity during the signal window while the Doppler signals from arteries are markedly nonstationary. The Wigner-Ville (WVD), Choi-Williams (CWD) and Bessel distributions (BD), specifically designed for nonstationary signals, have been optimized for spectral width estimation accuracy and compared to the STFT under different signal to noise ratios using simulated Doppler signals of known time-frequency characteristics. The optimum parameter values for each method were determined as a Hanning window duration of 10 ms for the SFTF, 40 ms for the WVD and CWD and 20 ms for the BD and dimensionless time-frequency smoothing constant values of five in the CWD and two in the BD. Thresholding was used to reduce the effect of cross terms and side lobes in the WVD and BD. With no added noise the WVD gave the lowest estimation error followed by the CWD. At signal-to-noise ratios (SNR's) of 10 dB and 20 dB the CWD and BD had similar errors and were markedly better than the other estimators. Overall the CWD gave the best performance.