Antibody C Region Influences TGN1412-like Functional Activity In Vitro

The unexpected outcome of the clinical trial of the superagonistic CD28 mAb TGN1412 (IgG4 kappa) continues to stimulate interest. We show that TGN1412 binds similarly to human and cynomolgus macaque Fc gamma R, eliminating the possibility that differences in Fc-mediated interactions with Fc gamma R contributed to the failure of preclinical testing in macaques to predict toxicity in humans. The influence of the Fc domain and C region structure on the in vitro functional activity of TGN1412 was investigated using F(ab')(2) and Fab fragments derived from TGN1412 recovered from the trial and recombinant TGN1412 subclass variants and mutants. Superagonistic activity, as measured by cytokine release and proliferation, was assessed by exposing PBMCs to immobilized mAbs/fragments or to aqueous mAbs/fragments in the presence of HUVEC monolayers. Removing the Fc generally curtailed or abolished PBMC activation. However, eliminating detectable Fc gamma R-binding of the IgG4 by mutation (L235E) did not abrogate activity. Stabilizing the "wild-type" IgG4 hinge (S228P) enhanced activity without increasing Fc gamma R binding, which could only partially be explained by inhibition of Fab arm-exchange. Subclass switching the IgG4 mAb to IgG1 decreased activity, whereas switching to IgG2 markedly increased activity. We conclude that the C region strongly influences in vitro CD28-mediated superagonistic signaling. Superagonism requires an intact Fc, as shown by the absence of activity of TGN1412 Fab and F(ab')(2) fragments, but, notably, appears to be relatively independent of Fc gamma R-binding properties. We propose that the Fc, potentially through restricting flexibility, maintains a favorable V region conformation to allow superagonistic activity. These findings have important implications for Ab design strategies. The Journal of Immunology, 2012, 189: 5831-5840.