Demersal fish biomass size spectra on the Scotian Shelf, Canada: species replacement at the shelfwide scale

Three parameters were derived from annual biomass size spectra constructed for a 22-year time series of demersal fish data for the entire Scotian Shelf: (i) total sampled biomass density, (ii) modal body weight, and (iii) the shape of the various biomass size spectra. Temporal variability of these parameters was compared among six species groups and between the species groups and their total. Species-group biomass varied more over the time series than did the total biomass, indicating the presence of a system factor. Conversely, modal body weight was as variable, and sometimes more variable, for the total than it was within species groups, indicating variability mainly at the species level. The shape of the biomass size spectrum showed annual differences in variability owing mainly to contributions of species groups. This variability was higher than variability in the combined species totals. We conclude that total biomass is limited at the combined species (systemwide) level because it depends on energy input to the system. Variability is greater at the species group (subsystem) level because the multiage species-group biomasses do not equally reflect a given energy limitation. Neither modal body weight nor the shape of the biomass spectrum is sensitive to the degree of taxonomic aggregation, suggesting that both measures are independent of energy input (primary production). We found no evidence of consistent species replacement trends on the shelfwide scale and conclude that diffuse replacement best describes species succession on the Scotian Shelf as a whole.