Vitiligo: A retrospective comparative analysis of treatment modalities in 500 patients

The major non-surgical re-pigmenting therapies for vitiligo include psoralens and corticosteroids, used both topically and systemically. In an attempt to determine the best therapeutic option, we compared the efficacy of various treatment regimens used in our department for the treatment of vitiligo. We report herein our results with six different regimens used in our clinic. Data from five hundred vitiligo patients who attended the pigmentary disorders clinic at the Nehru Hospital, PGI, Chandigarh, was analysed. For the purpose of analysis, patients were arbitrarily divided into two groups based upon the body surface area (BSA) involved: Group A (< 10% BSA involved) and B (> 10% BSA involved). Group A was further divided into three subgoups of patients depending upon what treatment they received: R-I {topical clobetasol propionate+sun exposure}; R-II {topical psoralen+sun exposure (topical PUVASOL)}; R-III {topical psoralen+UVA (topical PUVA)}. Group B was also subdivided into three subgroups of patients who received: R-IV {oral dexamethasone pulse therapy + sun exposture}; R-V {systemic psoralen + sun exposure (systemic PUVASOL)}; R-VI {systemic psoralen + UVA (systemic PUVA)}. Patients who had undergone, one of the above mentioned regimens and had a regular monthly follow up until total re-pigmentation or for at least one year, whichever was earlier, were included in the final assessment of the therapeutic efficacy of that regimen. At the end of the study in Group A, 207 (89%) patients out of 232 on R-I; 73 (93%) out of 78 on R-II, and 15 (79%) out of 19 patients on R-III showed moderate to excellent re-pigmentation, respectively. In group B, 45 (81%) patients out of 55 on R-IV, 48 (84%) out of 57 on R-V, and 22 (84%) patients out of 26 on R-VI showed moderate to excellent re-pigmentation. Statistically, in Group A, R-I & II were significantly better than R-III. However in Group B, there was no significant difference in the responses to R-IV, V and VI. A positive family history of vitiligo did not seem to affect the response rate. Potent topical steroids used along with sun exposure and topical PUVASOL were the most effective forms of therapy for localised vitiligo. For the generalised form of the disease, we concluded that all the systemic modalities, oral steroids, PUVASOL and PUNA, are equally efficacious over a period of one year. Phototoxic reactions were, however, more common with PUVASOL.