A comparison of polymerization by light-emitting diode and halogen-based light-curing units

Background. Light-emitting diode, or LED, technology provides certain advantages over halogen-based light polymerization of resin-based composites. The authors investigated the adequacy of cure of LED light-curing units, 1 or LCUs. Methods. The authors used two halogen-based lightcuring units (Optilux 400 and 501, Demetron Research Corp., Danbury, Conn.) and two commercially available LED LCUs (LumaCure, LumaLite, Spring Valley, Calif., and VersaLux, Centrix, Shelton, Conn.) to polymerize top surfaces of hybrid (Filtek Z-250, 3M, St. Paul, Minn.) and microfilled (Renamel, Cosmedent, Chicago) resin-based composite specimens. Specimens were indented on their top and bottom surfaces with a Knoop hardness tester and measured for hardness. Bottom:top hardness ratios determined the percentage of cure. The authors separated the data into eight groups (two composites cured with four different lights) with 15 observations per group, for a total sample size of 120, Results. The authors compared composites and curing lights by a two-way analysis of variance, and results indicated significant main effects. The main effect of composite was statistically significant (P < .0001) when microfilled composite was compared with hybrid composite, regardless of curing light, for all top d b h d an ottom ar ness measurements, with the hybrid producing much higher hardness measurements overall. The main effect of light was significant as well (P <.0001), regardless of composite type, with the two halogen-based lights producing harder top and bottom composite surfaces than the two LED LCUs. l i Th l Conc us ons. e ight output of commercially available diodes for resin-based composite polymerization still requires improvement to rival the adequacy of cure of halogen-based LCUs. Additional studies are necessary. Clinical Implications. Commercially available LED LCUs were introduced just in the past year. However they may not ade, quately polymerize resin-based composites, which can lead to restoration failures and adverse pulpal responses to unpolymerized monomers.