The summer metabolic balance in the epilimnion of southeastern Quebec lakes

On the basis of data collected in Quebec lakes, del Giorgio and Peters (1994) and Carignan et al. (2000) have come to opposite conclusions regarding the metabolic balance between heterotrophy and autotrophy in lakes in general. In the present study, epilimnetic oxygen and carbon dioxide saturation was measured in 33 lakes front the St. Lawrence Lowlands region of Quebec to examine the extent of epilimnetic net heterotrophy (i.e.. O-2:CO2 balance) in lakes of different characteristics. We found that similar to75% of the lakes were under-saturated with oxygen and supersaturated with CO2. There was a strong negative relationship between the departures of O-2 and CO2 from saturation. What has not been noted elsewhere is that oxygen concentrations were negatively related to dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentration, and, therefore, metabolic gas balances could be predicted from DOC; a value between 4 and 6 mg L-1 DOC corresponds to metabolic equilibrium. Because most of the lakes in del Giorgio and Peters (1994) had DOC concentrations above this threshold and most lakes in Carignan et al. (2000) were below, their apparently contradictory conclusions can be reconciled within a larger general theory. Contrary to studies elsewhere, however, we found that the degree of oxygen undersaturation increased with lake trophic status. expressed either as total phosphorus or nitrogen concentrations.