A review of the collaborative exercises on DNA typing of the Spanish and Portuguese ISFH working group

被引:13
作者
Gomez, J
RodriguezCalvo, MS
Albarran, C
Amorim, A
Andradas, J
Cabrero, C
Calvet, R
Corach, D
Crespillo, M
Doutremepuich, C
Garcia, O
Geada, H
Gene, M
Jimenez, S
Lorente, JA
MarquesSantos, SM
MartinezJarreta, B
dePancorbo, MM
Montes, F
delaCuesta, JMR
Sanz, P
TerraPinheiro, MF
Vide, MC
Carracedo, A
机构
[1] INST MED LEGAL,E-15705 SANTIAGO COMPOSTE,SPAIN
[2] INST NACL TOXICOL,MADRID,SPAIN
[3] IPATIMUP,OPORTO,PORTUGAL
[4] COMISARIA GEN POLICIA CIENT,LAB ADN,MADRID,SPAIN
[5] DPTO BIOL MOL,MADRID,SPAIN
[6] FAC MED,SANTANDER,SPAIN
[7] FAC FARM,SERV HUELLAS DIGITAL GENET,BUENOS AIRES,DF,ARGENTINA
[8] INST NACL TOXICOL,BARCELONA,SPAIN
[9] FAC PHARM,HEMATOL LAB,BORDEAUX,FRANCE
[10] AREA LAB ERTZAINTZA,BILBAO,SPAIN
[11] INST MED LEGAL,LISBON,PORTUGAL
[12] CATEDRA MED LEGAL,BARCELONA,SPAIN
[13] CATEDRA MED LEGAL,ALICANTE,SPAIN
[14] CATEDRA MED LEGAL,GRANADA,SPAIN
[15] LAB POLICIA CIENT,LISBON,PORTUGAL
[16] CATEDRA MED LEGAL,ZARAGOZA,SPAIN
[17] DPTO BIOL CELULAR & CIENCIAS MORFOL,LEIOA,PAIS VASCO,SPAIN
[18] DIRECC GEN GUARDIA CIVIL,DPTO ANAL,MADRID,SPAIN
[19] UNIV COMPLUTENSE MADRID,DPTO MED LEGAL & TOXICOL,MADRID,SPAIN
[20] INST NACL TOXICOL,SEVILLE,SPAIN
[21] INST MED LEGAL,OPORTO,PORTUGAL
[22] INST MED LEGAL,COIMBRA,PORTUGAL
关键词
DNA polymorphisms; standardization; collaborative exercise; forensics;
D O I
10.1007/s004140050084
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律]; R [医药、卫生];
学科分类号
0301 ; 10 ;
摘要
Since 1992 the Spanish and Portuguese Working Group (GEP) of the International Society for Forensic Haemogenetics (ISFH) has been organizing collaborative exercises on DNA profiling with the aim of making progress on standardization and discussing technical and statistical problems in DNA analysis. A total of four exercises (GEP-92 to GEP-95) have been carried out until now. A consequence of these exercises was the creation of a quality control programme in Spain and Portugal in 1995 which was carried out simultaneously with the GEP-95 exercise. The number of participating laboratories increased from 10 in the first exercise (GEP-92) to 19 in the last exercise (GEP-95). Despite this increasing number of participating laboratories, results remained satisfactory. In the last exercises, all the laboratories used PCR-based DNA polymorphisms with an increasing number of markers obtaining good results. SLPs were used by only 30% of laboratories in the last two exercises but the results indicated a good level of expertise in most of these laboratories. The reasons for these successful results are the common use of the EDNAP protocol for SLP analysis and commercially available kits or common sequenced allelic ladders for PCR-based DNA polymorphisms.
引用
收藏
页码:273 / 277
页数:5
相关论文
共 13 条
  • [1] BAR W, 1992, RECHTSMEDIZIN, V3, P6
  • [2] BRINKMANN B, 1993, RECHTSMEDIZIN, V3, P33
  • [3] BRINKMANN B, 1991, P 2 INT S HUM ID PRO, P211
  • [4] CARRACEDO A, 1996, IN PRESS P 1 EUR S H
  • [5] Elder JK, 1987, NUCLEIC ACID PROTEIN, P165
  • [6] REPORT OF THE EUROPEAN DNA PROFILING GROUP (EDNAP) - TOWARDS STANDARDIZATION OF SHORT TANDEM REPEAT (STR) LOCI
    GILL, P
    KIMPTON, C
    DALOJA, E
    ANDERSEN, JF
    BAR, W
    BRINKMANN, B
    HOLGERSSON, S
    JOHNSSON, V
    KLOOSTERMAN, AD
    LAREU, MV
    NELLEMANN, L
    PFITZINGER, H
    PHILLIPS, CP
    SCHMITTER, H
    SCHNEIDER, PM
    STENERSEN, M
    [J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1994, 65 (01) : 51 - 59
  • [7] A REPORT OF AN INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIVE EXPERIMENT TO DEMONSTRATE THE UNIFORMITY OBTAINABLE USING DNA PROFILING TECHNIQUES
    GILL, P
    WOODROFFE, S
    BAR, W
    BRINKMANN, B
    CARRACEDO, A
    ERIKSEN, B
    JONES, S
    KLOOSTERMAN, AD
    LUDES, B
    MEVAG, B
    PASCALI, VL
    RUDLER, M
    SCHMITTER, H
    SCHNEIDER, PM
    THOMSON, JA
    [J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1992, 53 (01) : 29 - 43
  • [8] Gomez J, 1996, ADV FOREN H, V6, P695
  • [9] REPORT ON THE 2ND EDNAP COLLABORATIVE STR EXERCISE
    KIMPTON, C
    GILL, P
    DALOJA, E
    ANDERSEN, JF
    BAR, W
    HOLGERSSON, S
    JACOBSEN, S
    JOHNSSON, V
    KLOOSTERMAN, AD
    LAREU, MV
    NELLEMANN, L
    PFITZINGER, H
    PHILLIPS, CP
    RAND, S
    SCHMITTER, H
    SCHNEIDER, PM
    STERNERSEN, M
    VIDE, MC
    [J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1995, 71 (02) : 137 - 152
  • [10] PUERS C, 1992, RECHTSMEDIZIN, V2, P99