A Petri Net-Based Model for Verification of Obligations and Accountability in Cooperative Systems

In cooperative systems (CSs), participants cannot usually ensure the correct behavior of their partners. Obligations and proofs of participants have to be performed together to achieve a common goal in a real cooperation. Without adequate accountability assurances of actions, there is no means of reliably enforcing punitive measures against fraudulent participants. However, the existing formal methods for analyzing CSs cannot properly deal with accountability and obligations. As such, this paper proposes a new class of labeled Petri net (LPN) models. The behavior of each partner is represented by an LPN, while a CS is modeled by the combination of all partners' LPN models. The behavioral properties of an overall modeled system can be well verified only by analyzing each individual LPN. LPNs provide the integration of formal notations with graphical notations and formal proofs with commonly used verification techniques. The obligations are verified based on LPN languages and the non-blocking properties of action sequences, while accountability can be proved by the network conditions and local action sequences on each partner's side. The proposed approaches are illustrated with the modeling and analysis of a Purchase transaction using the Internet Open Trading Protocol.