Audit of a melanoma screening day in the UK: clinical results, participant satisfaction and perceived value

Background The incidence of cutaneous malignant melanoma (MM) has risen significantly over the last 50 years in caucasian populations. Mortality is related to the Breslow thickness of the lesion, and early detection followed by complete surgical excision is crucial to reducing this. Skin screening events have been advocated as a means of detecting greater numbers of Mms in the earlier and thinner stages. Objectives To assess the feasibility and effectiveness of this approach in the U.K. Methods The Department of Dermatology, Singleton Hospital, Swansea, U.K. offered a 1-day melanoma screening event in summer 1998 at which 832 consecutive individuals were seen. A postal questionnaire 1 year after the event audited participant perceived value and satisfaction. Results Three MMs were identified (yield 1:277), all <0.75 mm in thickness. Despite high participant satisfaction and perceived value, the pick-up rate of malignancy was significantly lower than at rapid access pigmented lesion clinics. Conclusions In a country such as the U.K., with comprehensive health coverage and a low incidence of MM, triage for melanoma and referral to specialists by general practitioners may be more cost and time effective.