Health risk assessment of drinking water contaminants in Canada: The applicability of mixture risk assessment methods

被引:27
作者
Krishnan, K
Paterson, J
Williams, DT
机构
[1] HLTH CANADA,DRINKING WATER SECT,MONITORING & CRITERIA DIV,ENVIRONM HLTH DIRECTORATE,OTTAWA,ON K1A 0L2,CANADA
[2] HLTH CANADA,ENVIRONM HLTH DIRECTORATE,MONITORING & CRITERIA DIV,ENVIRONM CHEM SECT,OTTAWA,ON K1A 0L2,CANADA
关键词
D O I
10.1006/rtph.1997.1151
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律]; R [医药、卫生];
学科分类号
0301 ; 10 ;
摘要
The objectives of this article are: (i) to review the current approaches of Health Canada to the risk assessment of drinking water contaminants, and (ii) to examine the applicability of mixture risk assessment methods to drinking water contaminants. Health Canada's current approaches to drinking water risk assessment, like those of many regulatory agencies, focus almost solely on the effects of individual chemicals. As such, no formal method is currently used for developing mixtures guidelines or for modifying guidelines of individual chemicals to account for the possibility of the occurrence of interactions (supraadditive or infraadditive), Recent interest in the risk assessment of mixtures, at least in part, stems from concerns over the potential health risks of mixtures of very commonly occurring compounds in Canadian drinking water supplies, namely the disinfection byproducts. Before any mixtures methods can be considered for incorporation into Health Canada's current approaches to the risk assessment of drinking water contaminants, it is essential to consider the limitations and data requirements of the various mixture risk assessment methods (i.e., whole mixture approach, similar mixture approach, components-based approaches, interactions-based assessment). Among the existing mixture risk assessment methods, the components-based and interactions-based approaches could be applicable to drinking water contaminants. Specifically, among the components-based approaches, dose-addition response-addition, and the toxic equivalency factor approaches are the most applicable ones for drinking water contaminants. Until an interactions-based, mechanistic risk assessment approach (e.g., physiological model-based approach) becomes available for routine use, the components-based approaches remain the default methods for consideration. Progress in the development and validation of an interactions-based risk assessment methodology should facilitate a more realistic assessment of risk due to drinking water contaminants without increasing the levels of uncertainty in risk estimates above those associated with existing single-chemical methods. (C) 1997 Academic Press.
引用
收藏
页码:179 / 187
页数:9
相关论文
共 37 条
  • [1] Water chlorination: Essential process or cancer hazard?
    Bull, RJ
    Birnbaum, LS
    Cantor, KP
    Rose, JB
    Butterworth, BE
    Pegram, R
    Tuomisto, J
    [J]. FUNDAMENTAL AND APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 1995, 28 (02): : 155 - 166
  • [2] DICHLOROACETIC ACID AND TRICHLOROACETIC-ACID INCREASE CHLOROFORM TOXICITY
    DAVIS, ME
    [J]. JOURNAL OF TOXICOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, 1992, 37 (01): : 139 - 148
  • [3] *DEP NAT HLTH WELF, 1969, CAN DRINK WAT STAND
  • [4] Health Canada, 1995, GUID CAN DRINK WAT 1
  • [5] *HLTH CAN, 1996, GUD CAN DRINK WAT QU
  • [6] *HLTH CAN, 1993, GUID CAN DRINK WAT 2
  • [7] *HLTH CAN, 1994, EN4021541E DSS SUPPL
  • [8] KEEGAN TE, 1997, FUNDAM APPL TOXICO S, V36, P153
  • [9] Krewski D, 1995, J Biopharm Stat, V5, P245
  • [10] A MODEL-FREE APPROACH TO LOW-DOSE EXTRAPOLATION
    KREWSKI, D
    GAYLOR, D
    SZYSZKOWICZ, M
    [J]. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PERSPECTIVES, 1991, 90 : 279 - 285