Assessment of vulvovaginal complaints: Accuracy of telephone triage and in-office diagnosis

被引:48
作者
Allen-Davis, JT
Beck, A
Parker, R
Ellis, JL
Polley, D
机构
[1] Kaiser Permanente, Dept Obstet & Gynecol, Wheat Ridge, CO 80033 USA
[2] Kaiser Permanente, Clin Res Unit, Wheat Ridge, CO 80033 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1016/S0029-7844(01)01670-2
中图分类号
R71 [妇产科学];
学科分类号
100211 ;
摘要
OBJECTIVE: To examine the agreement between telephone and office management of vulvovaginal complaints and to assess the accuracy of diagnosis of vulvovaginitis. METHODS: Prospective structured telephone nurse interviews of all patients with vulvovaginal complaints who called the Kaiser Permanente Telephone Call Center were conducted. Patients were appointed to a physician, nurse midwife, or physician's assistant for office evaluation. Both groups (nurses and practitioners) made independent diagnosis and treatment decisions. kappa coefficients were used to evaluate the interexaminer agreement between telephone nurses and practitioners, and practitioners and traditional diagnostic tests. RESULTS: A total of 485 patients underwent telephone interviews, and 253 (52%) completed the study protocol. kappa values showed poor agreement between nurses and practitioners for bacterial vaginosis (0.12), candidiasis (0.22), and trichomoniasis (-0.05). Practitioners failed to accurately diagnose vaginitis when kappa values were analyzed. There was also poor agreement between telephone nurses and practitioners regarding the necessity of an office visit (0.14). CONCLUSION: This prospective study challenges the notion that the telephone is an effective tool to diagnose and treat vulvovaginal complaints. Moreover, given the poor agreement between practitioners' diagnoses and microbiologic and microscopic data, further study into optimal diagnosis of vulvovaginitis is needed. (C) 2002 by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
引用
收藏
页码:18 / 22
页数:5
相关论文
共 9 条
  • [1] DONOVAN RJ, 1997, AUST NZ J PUBL HEAL, V21, P131
  • [2] Agreement between face-to-face and telephone-administered mood ratings in patients with rapid cycling bipolar disorder
    FeldmanNaim, S
    Myers, FS
    Clark, CH
    Turner, EH
    Leibenluft, E
    [J]. PSYCHIATRY RESEARCH, 1997, 71 (02) : 129 - 132
  • [3] FLEISS JL, 1981, STAT METHODOLOGY RAT
  • [4] Iglesias EA, 2000, INFECT MED, V17, P175
  • [5] DECISION-MAKING STRATEGIES FOR TELEPHONE TRIAGE IN EMERGENCY MEDICAL-SERVICES
    LEPROHON, J
    PATEL, VL
    [J]. MEDICAL DECISION MAKING, 1995, 15 (03) : 240 - 253
  • [6] POOLE SR, 1993, PEDIATRICS, V92, P6709
  • [7] Telephone versus in-person clinical and health status assessment interviews in patients with bipolar disorder
    Revicki, DA
    Tohen, M
    Gyulai, L
    Thompson, C
    Pike, S
    DavisVogel, A
    Zarate, C
    [J]. HARVARD REVIEW OF PSYCHIATRY, 1997, 5 (02) : 75 - 81
  • [8] Comparability of telephone and face-to-face interviews in assessing axis I and II disorders
    Rohde, P
    Lewinsohn, PM
    Seeley, JR
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 1997, 154 (11) : 1593 - 1598
  • [9] SRAMEK M, 1994, BRIT HEART J, V71, P440