Comparison of out of hours care provided by patients' own general practitioners and commercial deputising services: A randomised controlled trial .1. The outcome of care

被引:41
作者
McKinley, RK
Cragg, DK
Hastings, AM
French, DP
MankuScott, TK
Campbell, SM
Van, F
Roland, MO
Roberts, C
机构
[1] UNIV MANCHESTER, RUSHOLME HLTH CTR, DEPT GEN PRACTICE, MANCHESTER M14 5NP, LANCS, ENGLAND
[2] UNIV MANCHESTER, NATL PRIMARY CARE RES & DEV CTR, MANCHESTER M13 9PL, LANCS, ENGLAND
来源
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL | 1997年 / 314卷 / 7075期
关键词
D O I
10.1136/bmj.314.7075.190
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective: To compare the outcome of out of hours care given by general practitioners from patients' own practices and by commercial deputising services. Design: Randomised controlled trial. Setting: Four urban areas in Manchester, Salford, Stockport, and Leicester. Subjects: 2152 patients who requested out of hours care, and 49 practice doctors and 183 deputising doctors (61% local principals in general practice) who responded to the requests. Main outcome measures: Health status outcome, patient satisfaction, and subsequent health sen ice use. Results: Patients seen by deputising doctors were less satisfied with the care they received. The mean overall satisfaction score for practice doctors was 70.7 (95% confidence interval 68.1 to 73.2) and for deputising doctors 61.8 (59.9 to 63.7), The greatest difference in satisfaction was with the delay in visiting. There were no differences in the change in health or overall health status measured 24 to 120 hours after the out of hours call or subsequent use of the health service in the two groups. Conclusions: Patients are more satisfied with the out of hours care provided by practice doctors than that provided by deputising doctors, Organisation of doctors into large groups ma) produce lower levels of patient satisfaction, especially when associated with increased delays in the time taken to visit There seem to be no appreciable differences in health outcome between the two types of service.
引用
收藏
页码:190 / 193
页数:4
相关论文
共 25 条
[1]  
BAKER R, 1995, BRIT J GEN PRACT, V45, P654
[2]  
BAKER R, 1990, BRIT J GEN PRACT, V40, P487
[3]   OUT-OF-HOURS VISITS [J].
BAKER, R ;
MCKINLEY, R .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 310 (6978) :533-534
[4]   PATIENTS ASSESSMENT OF OUT OF HOURS CARE IN GENERAL-PRACTICE [J].
BOLLAM, MJ ;
MCCARTHY, M ;
MODELL, M .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1988, 296 (6625) :829-832
[5]   VALIDATING THE SF-36 HEALTH SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE - NEW OUTCOME MEASURE FOR PRIMARY CARE [J].
BRAZIER, JE ;
HARPER, R ;
JONES, NMB ;
OCATHAIN, A ;
THOMAS, KJ ;
USHERWOOD, T ;
WESTLAKE, L .
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1992, 305 (6846) :160-164
[6]   Comparison of out of hours care provided by patients' own general practitioners and commercial deputising services: A randomised controlled trial .1. The process of care [J].
Cragg, DK ;
McKinley, RK ;
Roland, MO ;
Campbell, SM ;
Van, F ;
Hastings, AM ;
French, DP ;
MankuScott, TK ;
Roberts, C .
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1997, 314 (7075) :187-189
[7]   A CASE AGAINST DEPUTIZING SERVICES [J].
CREIGHTON, PA .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1982, 284 (6322) :1090-1091
[8]   PATIENT SATISFACTION WITH GENERAL-PRACTITIONER DEPUTIZING SERVICES [J].
DIXON, RA ;
WILLIAMS, BT .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1988, 297 (6662) :1519-1522
[9]  
FITZPATRICK R, 1993, BRIT J RHEUMATOL, V32, P807
[10]  
Garratt A M, 1994, Qual Health Care, V3, P186, DOI 10.1136/qshc.3.4.186