Variability in zinc tolerance, measured as incorporation of radio-labeled carbon dioxide and thymidine, in periphyton communities sampled from 15 European river stretches

Fifteen European rivers and streams belonging to watersheds in Sweden, the Netherlands, and Spain respectively, were sampled by allowing periphyton to colonize submerged glass substrata. Their zinc tolerances were quantified in short-term laboratory tests, where inhibition of photosynthesis in microalgae and thymidine incorporation in bacterial DNA was measured, and expressed as EC50 values. The variability in zinc tolerances was high reaching 1.5-2.5 orders of magnitude, ranging from 25-8145 muM for photosynthesis and 15467 muM for thymidine assays. Based on the observed variability, uncertainty factors were estimated for the extrapolation of zinc toxicity data from river to river, both regionally and interregionally. Under the assumption to protect 95% of the observed communities the regional uncertainty factors were 1.7-4.3 and the interregional 2.4-8.6. The sampling sites were characterized in terms of biotope physiography, water chemistry, periphyton biomass, trace element content, and species composition. Multivariate analysis of the data using PLS (Projection to Latent Structure), was used to generate hypotheses about the relation between periphyton zinc tolerance and the 123 so-called predictor variables. Zinc contamination, phosphate, nitrogen nutrients, pH, calcium, bicarbonate, dissolved organic carbon, and various diatom species are important predictors for zinc tolerance in the entire data set representing all 15 river stretches. Regional models suggested that very different factors determined the zinc tolerance in the Swedish and Dutch periphyton. The results are interpreted in terms of Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance (PICT) and the bioavailability of zinc.