The relative importance of nutrient enrichment and herbivory on macroalgal communities near Norman's Pond Cay, Exumas Cays, Bahamas: a "natural" enrichment experiment

The simultaneous effects of grazing and nutrient enrichment on macroalgal communities were experimentally investigated using plastic mesh enclosure/exclosure cages along a natural nutrient (DIN, SPP) gradient from the discharge of a tidal mangrove creek on the west side of Norman's Pond Cay, Exumas Cays, Bahamas. Nutrient enrichment was the only factor affecting total biomass of macroalgae whereas selective herbivory moderated species composition. Biomass ranged from >2 kg dry weight m(-2) at the DIN-enriched Waterfall to < 600 g dry weight m(-2) in the DIN-limited Algal Halo. Grazing by the queen conch Strombus gigas and the sea hare Aplysia dactylomela significantly reduced biomass of the epiphyte Laurencia intricata, but not its host Digenea simplex at the DIN-enriched Waterfall. These two rhodophytes dominated the macroalgal community at the DIN-enriched Waterfall and inner Algal Halo, whereas the chlorophytes Microdictyon marinum and Cladophora catenata dominated the relatively DIN-depleted outer Algal Halo. Higher grazing rates by S. gigas, A. dactylomela, and juvenile parrotfish and surgeonfish at the DIN-enriched Waterfall compared to the more oligotrophic Algal Halo suggested selective grazing on higher quality (nitrogen) diets by these herbivores. A pronounced increase in the carbon/nitrogen (C:N) ratios of D. simplex and L. intricata from the Water-fall to the Algal Halo indicated increased DIN-limitation of growth in the more offshore, lower DIN macroalgal communities. In contrast, only modest increases in C:N ratios of M. marinum and C. catenata between the Water-fall and Algal Halo suggested that these species are better adapted to growth in reef environments with lower levels of DIN enrichment. Low coral cover (<2%) co-occurred with high macroalgal cover (>35%) at DIN-enriched reef sites around Norman's Pond Cay (Waterfall, Patch Reef, North Perry Reef) compared to relatively high coral cover (10-20%) and low macroalgal cover (<20%) at the lower DIN reef sites (Rainbow Reef, Lang's Reef). These results support ecological theory that bottom-up control via nutrient enrichment is a primary factor regulating overall biomass and taxonomic assemblages of macroalgae on coral reefs, whereas grazing is more important in controlling relative species composition via dietary preferences. (C) 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.