Chemical and mineralogical forms of Cu and Ni in contaminated soils from the Sudbury mining and smelting region, Canada

Available information on soil contamination by trace elements in the Sudbury Cu/Ni mining and smelting region consists largely of total elemental concentration data. Little is known about the mode of occurrence and behaviour of Cu and Ni (the main metallic contaminants) in the soils of the region. In this study, sequential extraction and Scanning Electron Microscopy and Energy Dispersive X-ray Analysis (SEM/EDX) observations were complementarily used to define Cu and Ni forms in the Sudbury soils, so as to assess metal mobility. Most Cu (on average 75%) was associated with 'non-residual' soil forms, whereas Ni was mainly (on average 60%) associated with inorganic 'residual' forms of a sulphide and oxide nature. Therefore, Cu occurs in the soils in more mobile forms than Ni. Consequently, Cu should be removed from these soils at a faster rate than Ni. This is an unusual finding, because generally Ni is known to be more mobile in soils than Cu. SEM/EDX analysis confirmed the greater Cu mobility by showing that the metal was strongly associated with organic matter and was homogeneously distributed on the clay fraction surfaces. Nickel occurred alone or was associated with Fe oxides in various size fractions. Both elements were found as sulphides but Ni was often included in the silicate matrices of spherical particles in associations with Fe. SEM/EDX observations have shown that Cu and Ni are associated with soil forms which would not have been predicted by the sequential extraction alone, such as carbonaceous material, silicate spheres and carbonate particles, supporting complementary use of the two techniques.