Free radical scavenging alleviates the biomechanical impairment of gamma radiation sterilized bone tissue

Terminal sterilization of bone allografts by gamma radiation is often essential prior to their clinical use to minimize the risk of infection and disease transmission. While gamma radiation has efficacy superior to other sterilization methods it also impairs the material properties of bone allografts, which may result in premature clinical failure of the allograft. The mechanisms by which gamma radiation sterilization damages bone tissue are not well known although there is evidence that the damage is induced via free radical attack on the collagen. In the light of the existing literature, it was hypothesized that gamma radiation induced biochemical damage to bone's collagen that can be reduced by scavenging for the free radicals generated during the ionizing radiation. It was also hypothesized that this lessening of the extent of biochemical degradation of collagen will be accompanied by alleviation in the extent of biomechanical impairment secondary to gamma radiation sterilization. Standardized tensile test specimens machined from human femoral cortical bone and specimens were assigned to four treatment groups: control, scavenger treated-control, irradiated and scavenger treated-irradiated. Thiourea was selected as the free radical scavenger and it was applied in aqueous form at the concentration of 1.5 M. Monotonic and cyclic mechanical tests were conducted to evaluate the mechanical performance of the treatment groups and the biochemical integrity of collagen molecules were assessed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The native mechanical properties of bone tissue did not change by thiourea treatment only. The effect of thiourea treatment on mechanical properties of irradiated specimens were such that the post-yield energy, the fracture energy and the fatigue life of thiourea treated-irradiated treatment group were 1.9-fold, 3.3-fold and 4.7-fold greater than those of the irradiated treatment group, respectively. However, the mechanical function of thiourea treated and irradiated specimens was not to the level of unirradiated controls. The damage occurred through the cleavage of the collagen backbone as revealed by SDS PAGE analysis. Irradiated specimens did not exhibit a noteworthy amount of intact a-chains whereas those irradiated in the presence of thiourea demonstrated intact a-chains. Results demonstrated that free radical damage is an important pathway of damage, caused by cleaving the collagen backbone. Blocking the activity of free radicals using the scavenger thiourea reduces the extent of damage to collagen, helping to maintain the mechanical strength of sterilized tissue. Therefore, free radical scavenger thiourea has the potential to improve the functional life-time of the allograft component following transplantation. (c) 2005 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.