Compliance with and accuracy of daily self-assessment of peak expiratory flows (PEF) in asthmatic subjects over a three month period

Serial peak expiratory flow (PEF) assessment has been proposed in the clinical evaluation of asthma. In subjects attending the asthma clinic of a tertiary care hospital, we wanted to assess: 1) compliance in performing PEF; and 2) accuracy of a PEF-diary. Twenty adult asthmatic subjects, all using inhaled steroids, were asked to assess their PEF in the morning and evening with a VMX instrument (Clement Clarke Int., Colombus, OH, USA). This instrument, which incorporates a standard mini-Wright peak flow meter, stores PEF data on a computer chip, Subjects were not informed that the values were being stored. The mean duration of PEF monitoring was 89 days (range 44-131 days). For the total of 20 subjects, it was estimated that 3,482 values should have been written down and stored on the VMX computer chip. Whilst 1,897 values (54%) were written down, only 1,533 (44%) were stored, 425 values being invented. Morning and evening values were stored on 34% of days; and values were stored at least once a day on 55% of days. The values written down corresponded precisely to stored values 90% of the time, and were within +/-20 L 94% of the time. We conclude that: 1) compliance with daily peak expiratory flow assessments is generally poor in chronic stable asthmatic subjects assessed on two visits separated by a 3 month period; and 2) a substantial percentage of values (22%) is invented. The unsatisfactory compliance with peak expiratory flow monitoring in this group of asthmatics on inhaled steroids underlines the need for similar studies on peak expiratory flow monitoring as part of an action treatment plan, and in more severe and brittle asthmatics.