Combined aortic and renal artery surgery - A contemporary experience

Purpose This retrospective study examines results with simultaneous aortic and renal artery repair in 133 consecutive hypertensive patients. These results are compared with consecutive patient groups undergoing aortic reconstruction alone (269 patients) or renal artery reconstruction alone (182 patients). Methods From January 1987 through July 1995, 61 women and 72 men (mean age, 62.5 years) underwent combined repair of renal artery and aortic disease (abdominal aortic aneurysm [AAA]: 47 patients; occlusive disease: 86 patients; both: 12 patients). All patients were hypertensive (mean blood pressure: 194/103 mmHg; mean medications: 2.4). Evidenced by serum creatinine levels greater than or equal to 2.0 mg/dL, 46 patients (35%) had significant renal dysfunction (mean serum creatinine level: 3.78 mg/dL; range, 2.0-10.6 mg/dL, including 7 dialysis-dependent patients). Aortic replacements (29% tube grafts; 71% bifurcated grafts) were combined with unilateral renal artery repair in 47% of patients; 53% had bilateral repair. Preoperative clinical features and perioperative mortality were compared with those groups having isolated aortic and renal repairs. Results There were seven perioperative deaths (5.3%) after combined repair, which differed significantly from isolated aortic repair (mortality. 0.74%; p = 0.005), but did not reach statistical significance when compared with the isolated renal artery group (mortality: 1.65%; p = 0.145). Risk analysis did not reveal a significant association between preoperative clinical features and mortality in either the combined repair group or the groups undergoing renal repair alone or aortic repair alone. Among survivors in the combined group, a favorable hypertension response was observed in 63%. This differed significantly from the group receiving renal repair alone (90% cured/improved; p < 0.001). Based on a 20% decrease in serum creatinine levels, excretory renal function was improved in 33% of patients with combined repair, including four of the seven patients removed from hemodialysis. There were eight late deaths in the combined group. Conclusions Our experience suggests that contemporary perioperative mortality for combined aortic and renal repair has improved compared with earlier reports; however, perioperative mortality for simultaneous reconstruction remains greater than repair of aortic disease alone. Moreover, a lower rate of favorable hypertension response was observed after combined correction compared with renal artery repair alone. These differences suggest that aortic and renal artery repair should only be combined for clinical indications rather than for prophylactic repair of clinically silent disease.