Dynamical transition of myoglobin in a crystal: comparative studies of X-ray crystallography and Mossbauer spectroscopy

The crystallographic normal mode refinements of myoglobin at a wide range of temperature from 40 K to 300 K were carried out to study the temperature dependence of the internal atomic fluctuations. The refinement method decomposes the mean square displacement from the average position, (Deltar(2)), into the contributions from the internal degrees of freedom and those from the external degrees of freedom. The internal displacements show linear temperature dependence as (Deltar(2)) = alphaT + beta, throughout the temperature range measured here, and exhibit no obvious change in the slope a at the dynamical transition temperature (T-c = ca. 180 K). The slope alpha is practically the same as the value predicted theoretically by normal mode analysis. Such linear dependence is considered to be due to the following reason. The crystallographic Debye-Waller factor represents the static distribution caused by convolution of temperature-dependent normal mode motions and a temperature-independent set of the conformational substates. In contrast, Mossbauer absorption spectroscopy shows a clear increase in the gradient alpha at T-c. This difference from X-ray diffraction originates from the incoherent nature of the Mossbauer effect together with its high-energy resolution, which yields the self-correlation, and the temporal behavior of individual Fe atoms in the myoglobin crystal.