The effects of non-homology in RAPD bands on similarity and multivariate statistical ordination in Brassica and Helianthus

In order to estimate the impact of mis-coding non-homologous, co-migrating DNA bands as homologous, two sets of data were utilized. Analyses were conducted using three Helianthus species in which each co-migrating band had previously been confirmed. Comparisons of the similarities between these three Helianthus species using the original 177 RAPD bands and the corrected, homology verified, 197 RAPD band data set revealed that the triangular relationship among these three species was almost identical in both data sets. The non-homology errors in the Helianthanus data sets were found to be random. These random errors merely reduced the absolute similarities, but not the relative similarities nor the relationships among the taxa, in principal-coordinate-analysis ordination. Analyses of RAPDs for the classical Brassica U triangle were made by inserting random non-homologies for 5, 10, 15 and 20% of the original 220 RAPD bands. These analyses revealed a progressive decrease in similarities and less loading on the first two axes in principal coordinate analysis (PCO). However, the basic U triangle of relationships among these six Brassica species was maintained. It appears that if errors in homology of co-migrating DNA bands are random, this will have little effect on the relative similarities and on PCO ordination. This helps explain the successful use of RAPDs at the specific level.