Body size and substrate association of littoral insects in relation to vegetation structure

Variation in substrate association types and maximum size of aquatic insects were studied in a vegetated littoral zone of three lake basins. The basins differed from each other in trophic status, biomass of benthivorous fish, and abundance of macrophytes. Four types of substrate association - swimmers, crawlers, semisessiles and burrowers, respectively - were assumed to represent decreasing vulnerability to fish predators. Large-sized species were also hypothesised to be more vulnerable to fish predators. The distributions of species traits were examined in relation to vegetation density. Inferring from "predation hypothesis" opposite selection pressures on the species traits were expected along the vegetation density. Dense macrophyte beds were thought to be dominated by invertebrate predators and open water by fish predators, since the predation efficiency of fish decreases in complex environments. In the case of invertebrate predator domination, large size and higher activity should be favoured traits among the prey species. Distribution patterns of modes of the two studied traits were explored separately for predatory and nonpredatory insects. As expected, swimmers and large-sized crawlers were characteristic of the insect assemblages of dense macrophyte beds. The densities of Odonata, Corixidae, Dytiscidae, Ephemeroptera and Sialidae were higher among macrophytes than in open water, where these insect taxa were possibly depleted by fish. On the other hand, the small-sized and fairly immobile Chironomidae were the most abundant group in open water. These results support the existence of a predator transition zone among littoral vegetation, ranging from domination of invertebrate predation among the dense beds to that of fish predation in open water.