The placebo needle, is it a valid and convincing placebo for use in acupuncture trials? A randomised, single-blind, cross-over pilot trial

被引:171
作者
White, P
Lewith, G
Hopwood, V
Prescott, P
机构
[1] Univ Southampton, Royal S Hants Hosp, Complementary Med Res Unit, Southampton SO9 5NH, Hants, England
[2] Univ Southampton, Dept Math, Southampton SO9 5NH, Hants, England
关键词
acupuncture; placebo; placebo needle;
D O I
10.1016/j.pain.2003.08.013
中图分类号
R614 [麻醉学];
学科分类号
100217 ;
摘要
The issue of what constitutes an effective and realistic acupuncture placebo control has been a continuing problem for acupuncture research. In order to provide an effective placebo, the control procedure must be convincing, visible and should mimic, in all respects, apart from a physiological effect. the real active treatment. The 'Streitberger' needle might fulfil these criteria and this paper reports on a validation study. This was a single-blind. randomised, cross-over pilot study. Patients were drawn from the orthopaedic hip and knee, joint replacement waiting list. Intervention consisted of either 2 weeks of treatment with real acupuncture followed by 2 weeks on placebo, or vice versa. The prime outcome was a needle sensation questionnaire and there was a range of secondary outcomes. Thirty-seven patients were randomised and completed treatment. Groups were well balanced at baseline. No significant differences between groups or needle types were found for any of the sensations measured. Most patients were unable to discriminate between the needles by penetration; however, nearly 40% were able to detect a difference in treatment type between needles. No major differences in outcome between real and placebo needling could be found. The fact that nearly 40% of subjects did not find that the two interventions were similar, however, raises some concerns with regard to the wholesale adoption of this instrument as a standard acupuncture placebo. Further work on inter-tester reliability and standardisation of technique is highly recommended before we can be confident about using this needle in further studies. (C) 2003 International Association for the Study of Pain. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:401 / 409
页数:9
相关论文
共 14 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], COMPLEMENT THER MED
[2]   CREDIBILITY OF ANALOGUE THERAPY RATIONALES [J].
BORKOVEC, TD ;
NAU, SD .
JOURNAL OF BEHAVIOR THERAPY AND EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHIATRY, 1972, 3 (04) :257-260
[3]  
DELATORRE CS, 1993, FRONTIER PERSPECTIVE, V3, P33
[4]   A review of problems in clinical acupuncture research [J].
Ernst, E ;
White, AR .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CHINESE MEDICINE, 1997, 25 (01) :3-11
[5]  
FINNIGAN MD, 1991, COMPLEMENT MED RES, V5, P79
[6]   Placebo needle for acupuncture [J].
Kaptchuk, TJ .
LANCET, 1998, 352 (9132) :992-992
[7]   Randomised clinical trial comparing the effects of acupuncture and a newly designed placebo needle in rotator cuff tendinitis [J].
Kleinhenz, J ;
Streitberger, K ;
Windeler, J ;
Güssbacher, A ;
Mavridis, G ;
Martin, E .
PAIN, 1999, 83 (02) :235-241
[8]  
LEWITH G, 2000, UNPUB DOUBLE BLIND R
[9]   Do attitudes toward and beliefs about complementary medicine affect treatment outcomes? [J].
Lewith, GT ;
Hyland, ME ;
Shaw, S .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2002, 92 (10) :1604-1606
[10]  
LIANGYUE D, 1990, CHINESE ACUPUNCTURE