Randomised trial of histoacryl blue tissue adhesive glue versus suturing in the repair of paediatric lacerations

被引:33
作者
Barnett, P
Jarman, FC
Goodge, J
Silk, G
Aickin, R
机构
[1] Royal Childrens Hosp, Dept Emergency Med, Parkville, Vic 3052, Australia
[2] Royal Childrens Hosp, Ctr Community Child Hlth & Ambulatory Paediat, Parkville, Vic 3052, Australia
[3] Starship Childrens Hosp, Dept Emergency, Auckland, New Zealand
关键词
histoacryl; laceration; sutures; tissue adhesive glue;
D O I
10.1046/j.1440-1754.1998.00300.x
中图分类号
R72 [儿科学];
学科分类号
100202 ;
摘要
Objective: To compare histoacryl blue tissue adhesive glue with suturing in the repair of simple paediatric lacerations. Methodology: Prospective, randomised controlled trial in tertiary paediatric emergency department. Children 4 years old or older with non-ragged lacerations <5 cm in length, <12-h-old and not involving eyelid or mucous membrane. a total of 163 patients were randomly allocated to either glue (83 cases) or sutures (80 controls) to repair their laceration. Primary outcome measures were cosmetic outcome at 3 and 12 months with secondary outcomes-length of time to perform procedure, and pain assessment of procedure by doctor, nurse, parent and child. Results: Cases and controls were similar in age, wound length and width and body part involved, but more females received glue (P = 0.013). Time taken to repair the wound was faster in the glue group (median 0-2 mins vs. 6-10 min suture, P < 0.001). Doctors (P = 0.02), nurses (P < 0.01) and parents (P = 0.02) but not the children themselves (P = 0.24) rated glue repair as less distressing. Complications at I week (wound dehiscence, redness and discharge) were the same for both groups (P > 0.2), Cosmetic outcome was the same for both groups at 3 (n = 65) and 12 (n = 65) months (P > 0.7). Conclusion: Tissue adhesive glue is faster and probably less painful than suturing. Tissue adhesive glue has the same cosmetic result as suturing when used for the repair of simple lacerations in children.
引用
收藏
页码:548 / 550
页数:3
相关论文
共 13 条
[1]   THE FACES PAIN SCALE FOR THE SELF-ASSESSMENT OF THE SEVERITY OF PAIN EXPERIENCED BY CHILDREN - DEVELOPMENT, INITIAL VALIDATION, AND PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION FOR RATIO SCALE PROPERTIES [J].
BIERI, D ;
REEVE, RA ;
CHAMPION, GD ;
ADDICOAT, L ;
ZIEGLER, JB .
PAIN, 1990, 41 (02) :139-150
[2]  
Bruns TB, 1996, PEDIATRICS, V98, P673
[3]  
ELLIS DAF, 1990, J OTOLARYNGOL, V19, P68
[4]   USE OF TISSUE ADHESIVE IN THE CLOSURE OF SMALL INCISIONS AND LACERATIONS [J].
ELMASALME, FN ;
MATBOULI, SA ;
ZUBERI, MS .
JOURNAL OF PEDIATRIC SURGERY, 1995, 30 (06) :837-838
[5]   COMPARISON OF SILK SUTURES AND N-BUTYL-2-CYANOACRYLATE ON THE HEALING OF SKIN WOUNDS - A PILOT-STUDY [J].
GIRAY, CB ;
SUNGUR, A ;
ATASEVER, A ;
ARAZ, K .
AUSTRALIAN DENTAL JOURNAL, 1995, 40 (01) :43-45
[6]  
HEGENBARTH MA, 1990, ANN EMERG MED, V19, P111
[7]  
MESSI G, 1992, PANMINERVA MED, V34, P77
[8]  
MIDDLETON WG, 1991, J OTOLARYNGOL, V20, P363
[9]   ECONOMIC COMPARISON OF A TISSUE ADHESIVE AND SUTURING IN THE REPAIR OF PEDIATRIC FACIAL LACERATIONS [J].
OSMOND, MH ;
KLASSEN, TP ;
QUINN, JV .
JOURNAL OF PEDIATRICS, 1995, 126 (06) :892-895
[10]   SUPERGLUE SEALANT FOR PERSISTENT LEAKAGE OF CEREBROSPINAL-FLUID [J].
PAPINI, RPG ;
NIRANJAN, NS .
PLASTIC AND RECONSTRUCTIVE SURGERY, 1993, 91 (02) :371-372